*DISCONTINUED* Rares List Guide (1 March 2019)

[skyline]

i personally agree with this ^^

i don't believe demand should be removed entirely, as if that were to be the case, it may confuse newer users, or users in general. as yes, demand is user based, but people often tend to get ninjad out of higher demand pets, even though, "technically" speaking, it was a fair trade. this without a doubt happens a lot, and i think if the list is to be completely reconstructed, demand should not be completely removed for this reason. it needs to be taken into account somehow, as some users will get confused in various ways.

nevertheless, i'm glad to see the list being tended to properly, as it's been many years since the last full on update.

[ElementalInsanity]

This particular list will never not include demand, it’s impossible. It’s actually why the rarity only list was started.
If it were to not include demand we’d be placing pets without a poll based only on rarity. The poll itself is actually what brings in demand, as then a majority of people go on to vote based of personal preference and demand where they feel the pet goes.

[stan.]

@ElementalInsanity
Very well then and thank you very much for the clarification on that ^^, I think that's also a very good choice for this list. Definitlely makes it a more community based list, like it was aiming to.
But then perhaps the front page blurb that says "The list combines rarity, supply, demand, availability and circulation" could be adjusted or updated in the future to better reflect what this list is hoping to.
And after all, for any other purposes or ideas for demand/rarity placements, another list can be made, such as the demand list thread I saw floating around yesterday and the rarity list you mentioned.

So, moving on from that, has the next UR pet that will be moved decided yet?

[grey matter]

Uh, hi! I was told that I was given a tier 1 list pet but I don't even know where it is or what its "name" is. Is this a list pet and can I have a link to its pictured list position?

Pet's name: Child of Charity
Adopt virtual pets at Chicken Smoothie!
(Luckily it was a gift for free so don't go reporting the giver if it's not!!)

[jinbad]

Uh, hi! I was told that I was given a tier 1 list pet but I don't even know where it is or what its "name" is. Is this a list pet and can I have a link to its pictured list position?

Pet's name: Child of Charity
Adopt virtual pets at Chicken Smoothie!
(Luckily it was a gift for free so don't go reporting the giver if it's not!!)

It's on the first tier (bottom tier) of the Advent List under the name Green/Yellow Fluffy Store Dog.

Here's the link to the post of the Pictured List that it's on:
Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&t=3377402&start=10#p107203129

(You'll have to scroll fairly far down the post to see it!)

[Takk]

So, moving on from that, has the next UR pet that will be moved decided yet?

Don't think so. I'd prefer to do the grapes, UR Mint horse or Nick Unicorn next but I don't recall it being formally discussed

[Animall]

If I remember correctly, we were stuck between evaluating the bengal and foal when determining what to discuss last time. The bengal might be a good pet to discuss next, possibly? I’m not too picky regardless. I feel like the good demand of the bengal might be a relief for us though before going to another low demand pet.

[Targaryen]

If I remember correctly, we were stuck between evaluating the bengal and foal when determining what to discuss last time. The bengal might be a good pet to discuss next, possibly? I’m not too picky regardless. I feel like the good demand of the bengal might be a relief for us though before going to another low demand pet.

Yeah, I do think the Bengal should be discussed next. I'm getting a bit sick of people undercutting others with it's current list placement knowing it'll be raised drastically so I think it's important it's moved asap. And like you said, a bit of a relief from lower demand pets.

[ElementalInsanity]

I’d actually be interested in waiting to see if after the next rarity update the Bengal goes down to very rare again, so I don’t think waiting on it until then would be too horrible. ^^ if it doesn’t then totally fine, and if it does we’d have to adjust some things.

[Nettle_Magpie]

If the Bengal isn't going to be discussed should the UR fox be discussed or should that wait for the same reason? (I've been following the thread for a while, and it's been really helpful to keep up to date, so thanks guys)