The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Dayanaria]

Okay, so I'm in a bidding war for a winged blood dog, but I'm starting to think the price is getting ridiculous...

This is my offer for the dog:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... pid=241142

And this is my compititions offer:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... erid=24045

Are we both getting jipped by continuing this?

yes, your offer is considerably better than theirs. You have several valentines and advent pets, as well as many more pets.

But is it worth it is what I'm wondering? Should I withdraw my offer and see if I can find a better deal, or is this a really good deal for the winged blood dog?

[Kohaku]

Okay, so I'm in a bidding war for a winged blood dog, but I'm starting to think the price is getting ridiculous...

This is my offer for the dog:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... pid=241142

And this is my compititions offer:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... erid=24045

Are we both getting jipped by continuing this?

yes, your offer is considerably better than theirs. You have several valentines and advent pets, as well as many more pets.

But is it worth it is what I'm wondering? Should I withdraw my offer and see if I can find a better deal, or is this a really good deal for the winged blood dog?

Well, are either of your bids winning? I'm assuming not, but if that person is higher than you, than you should withdraw. The halloween pets have rarity now, so I think the pet is very rare. this also depends on how much you want the pet. It's your call, but I would go looking for a new auction if I were you (of course checking the offers in the other auctions before you do).

[Verd]

Which offer is best so far guys? I need an offer in the best spot. Can you help me out?
viewtopic.php?f=15&t=55973&p=1549381#p1549381

[evergreen]

on my side: winged halloween dog

their side: Ice pps, malk owl, malk cat, and march 09 bobtail dog with one blue eye one brown eye

[Pura]

My side: Tuft-eared halloween dog, Drink Me dog, Eat Me dog, Cerberus, Skeleton Bunny, and a Joker

Thier side: Gearback Tribal.

[Christy]

I dont know about that one I mean I traded one of my purple toxics for just a cerb

[Carm]

My side: Tuft-eared halloween dog, Drink Me dog, Eat Me dog, Cerberus, Skeleton Bunny, and a Joker

Thier side: Gearback Tribal.

Unfair; they should offer more.

[Rocka_Boo]

A Non Jewlery Sundog for a July 08 PPS?

Fair on Not?

[Tif + Jo]

A Non Jewlery Sundog for a July 08 PPS?

Fair on Not?

I know the trade is for me Rocka Boo, but I say definitely not a fair trade, there's no way I'd ever make you trade your PPS to me, he's too valuable to you and I don't want to take him from you ^^;

Besides, I would rather not have the trade unfair for you xD That's why I want it even and why I'm contemplating for what is a fair trade between you and I ^^

[Carm]

A Non Jewlery Sundog for a July 08 PPS?

Fair on Not?

I'd have to say unfair; I've heard that the July PPS is worth the same as a jewelry sundog. Maybe add a rarer July '08?