The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Cirque]

is this fair?

A july 08 PPS for 4 sorberts and a tribal?

Im just not sure :3

depends, if you're the one with the PPS-fair, if you're the one with the sorbets and tribal-not fair

[KyoshiYan]

that makes no sense xD you could just say yes or no xDDD

[Yukinstrüdel]

is this fair?

A july 08 PPS for 4 sorberts and a tribal?

Im just not sure :3

depends, if you're the one with the PPS-fair, if you're the one with the sorbets and tribal-not fair

lol, it's not fair if the sides have different fairness values... do you mean that it's a better deal for the person with the pps?

[Cirque]

is this fair?

A july 08 PPS for 4 sorberts and a tribal?

Im just not sure :3

depends, if you're the one with the PPS-fair, if you're the one with the sorbets and tribal-not fair

lol, it's not fair if the sides are different fair values... do you mean that it's a better deal for the person with the pps?

yeah, the person offering the sorbets and tribal are offering too much in my opinion so it's not fair for them

[Pastry]

depends, if you're the one with the PPS-fair, if you're the one with the sorbets and tribal-not fair

I've never understood answers like this.
How is it good for one person, but not the other.

[KyoshiYan]

plus a pps july 08 is worth up to 5 julys or 4 atleast *curses the rariety confusion anymore*

[Carm]

depends, if you're the one with the PPS-fair, if you're the one with the sorbets and tribal-not fair

I've never understood answers like this.
How is it good for one person, but not the other.

For one person it's a better deal, for the other it's an overoffer.

[Cirque]

depends, if you're the one with the PPS-fair, if you're the one with the sorbets and tribal-not fair

I've never understood answers like this.
How is it good for one person, but not the other.

For one person it's a better deal, for the other it's an overoffer.

exactly, like a person offering a zebra for a 2nd gen. good deal for the one with a 2nd gen. completely unfair for the zebra owner

[KyoshiYan]

I hope you know it is the 08 massively rare one and not this years one. -.-'

[moonlily]

is this fair?

A july 08 PPS for 4 sorberts and a tribal?

Im just not sure :3

Wow, forgive me for being contrary, but I would say definitely not. The july 08 PPS dogs are ridiculously rare. Before the December 18th box, I think Tess said there were only like 40 attached to accounts, and actually the rarest dog on CS. 'Course, that all changed thanks to last year's advent calendar, but they are still easily the equivalent of a moonswirl or jewelry sundog (if not quite as sought after). And I'm pretty sure you would not find people trading moonswirls and jewelry sundogs away for 5 of the most common august dogs. Just imho.