New Thread please lock <3

[Lufi]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ofgtox754w
Thanks

maybe fair?
he worthed many but him rarity went down

[kivr & fireflii]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Ofgtox754w
Thanks

I'd say a bit unfair to you

[|Hype|]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=9362664&userid=151034&signature=7Y_k_EkvrH5xFMW4qYLWmQ

I know this is unfair to them, but would you accept this if they sent it to you? (By the way, they did send it to me.)

[Mythicwave]

Which of these bids is fairest for the grinner, and, if it's unfair, what would need to be added?
This person knows it's unfair, but wants to try to make it fair. Any suggestions as to what to add?
Something around a Light Leopard/Target Dog value.

They said that this is just a starting bid and they WILL add more, when they get around to it.

The 2009 pets and the first two items are the only ones that catch my eye in this one, but I don't think it's fair as is. Any idea what they'd have to add, if I'm right about that?
Something like a Light Leopard, maybe less, though I'm not too sure about that one. This is the best bid thus far, though.
Edit: They edited, though I don't think it's too much better.

I'm also confused on my 2008 july VR green rat, which was said to be worth a balloon dog by some more experienced users. But I have two offers, supposedly unfair, but I'm not sure which is fairer and what needs to be added, or which one is better.
I heard fair before, but I was also told it was unfair to me by the friend that's more experienced in rarities than me. If they're correct, what do they need to add?
An Advent or perhaps a low September? Get a second opinion on this one. I personally do not know what the rat is worth.
Edit: I sent them a suggestion, telling them what was said. With what I did, is it fair? Or unfair to who?

I know the dragon is one step below the balloon dog, so, what fills the gap between the dragon and the balloon dog? Also, is this better than the first offer?
A mid or high September, I believe. I may be a bit off. I can't really say anything about which is better, though.
If you could help at all, thank you very much.

My answers are in bold^^

Thank you, and I'll keep your answers in.
Any other opinions, if I may ask?

[ki1im]

ok ill ask again

is this fair?? i just don't know as the store pets usually end up being very rares, really need someones help!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... P_yCG6lvQw

[Mythicwave]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=9362664&userid=151034&signature=7Y_k_EkvrH5xFMW4qYLWmQ

I know this is unfair to them, but would you accept this if they sent it to you? (By the way, they did send it to me.)

I personally would, even though it is unfair to them.
But if you'd rather it be less unfair to them before accepting, removing the rare on their side should help. Or, removing one of the uncommons.

[Shine]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... id=9363956
urgent need to know fair

[Mythicwave]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=9363956
urgent need to know fair

Cant see it. /:

IM IN DESPRETE NEED OF STEAK RAW OR COOKED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Wrong thread, and I'm sure you were looking for the swap thread?

[ki1im]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=9363956
urgent need to know fair

were unable to see the trade
you have to go to share trade and use that link

[|Hype|]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=9362664&userid=151034&signature=7Y_k_EkvrH5xFMW4qYLWmQ

I know this is unfair to them, but would you accept this if they sent it to you? (By the way, they did send it to me.)

I personally would, even though it is unfair to them.
But if you'd rather it be less unfair to them before accepting, removing the rare on their side should help. Or, removing one of the uncommons.

Ok thankyou!!!!!!!!!!!!!!