The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Aremisu]

Hi! are these trades fair? thank you!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78978003&userid=245540&signature=tbzfKxS9qJO5vvN59s89pg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78978014&userid=245540&signature=0m7uHpBcxYZd6LfOgXgtWw

[kkspecial4]

Hi! are these trades fair? thank you!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78978003&userid=245540&signature=tbzfKxS9qJO5vvN59s89pg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=78978014&userid=245540&signature=0m7uHpBcxYZd6LfOgXgtWw

Trade 01 -

Unfair to the bottom
The top only adds up to 1 2016 Uncommon + 1 2017 Uncommon
Trade 02 -

Unfair to the top side
But it is up to you on if you want to trade down the 2018 Rare or not

*Items for both evaluations were valued at 1 Common - if you value them at more/less it changes the evaluation

If you use the 4:1 Ratio -


2018 Rare = 4 2018 Uncommons = 2 2017 Uncommons

Unfair to the top by the 2018 Common pets and the 2017 Common/Very Common pets

3 2017 Commons = 1 2017 Common + 1 2017 Uncommon
2 2018 Commons = 1 2018 Uncommon
8 2018 Items = 1 2018 Common/Uncommon each = ~ 4 2018 Uncommons/8 2018 Uncommons
If you use the 2:1 Ratio -


2018 Rare = 2 2018 Uncommons = 1 2017 Uncommon

Unfair to the top by the 2018 Commons/Items and 1 2017 Common

3 2017 Commons = 1 2017 Common + 1 2017 Uncommon
2 2018 Commons = 1 2018 Uncommon
8 2018 Items = 1 2018 Common/Uncommon each = ~ 4 2018 Uncommons/8 2018 Uncommons

Again, math was done very quickly so I apologize for any mistakes/typos

[Redpanda]

Could I get some opinions on this?

[koalaplushie]

May I have an opinion on this trade? trades/viewtrade.php?id=78962410&userid=674298&signature=y0fdYWt6rklY7EiYcND5Bw im not the best with lists and I want to get close to the full worth of my UR lion. Thanks if you help :)

Also have this one too trades/viewtrade.php?id=78979057&userid=674298&signature=BNrXWZxKimTmPtrFXdHC-Q

[Kaminarii]

May I have an opinion on this trade? trades/viewtrade.php?id=78962410&userid=674298&signature=y0fdYWt6rklY7EiYcND5Bw im not the best with lists and I want to get close to the full worth of my UR lion. Thanks if you help

Also have this one too trades/viewtrade.php?id=78979057&userid=674298&signature=BNrXWZxKimTmPtrFXdHC-Q

It’s up to you, though the zebras have poor demand and can be quite difficult to trade off. I got a lot of offers with the zebras as people are trying to trade them off, personally I wouldent.

[Aurii]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78957552&userid=944839&signature=sHq_-D-FnyxXtz56EkFn-A

Or

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78951927&userid=944839&signature=NvFlgIn6rfn8s4IgPgyN6w

Or

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78951354&userid=944839&signature=cbTLnJcZDr2g5_NdkBqilQ

Or

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78967158&userid=944839&signature=q5b_lrUZ9_uiLirHvjIZ3A


Thank you. Two down. Which of these should I accept, assuming I value the zodiac at 2 2009 rares? Could I get better than any of these?

[Astellia]

Is this fair? I'm not good at rarity math haha. https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78979247&userid=814468&signature=eTHEJQStRkHBA9gs3Hc7nA

[skybristle]

Bids:
Bid 1 [2/10] I do like some of the pets but I have one of the stores and people on the Fair Trade thread said it was unfair.
Bid 2 [2/10] I do like some of the pets but I have one of the stores and people on the Fair Trade thread said it was unfair.
Bid 3 [8/10] I REALLY like the BMD in this trade, but I haven't had imput from the "Is This A Fair Trade?" thread. The BMD is a tier higher, plus the other rares and the staff dog is a nice boost.
Bid 4 [3/10] I think it's fair, but prefer my pets.
=Favorite
(copied from my auction post) The bidding isn't over, but I'd like to know!

[Seasonal]

Bids:
Bid 1 [2/10] I do like some of the pets but I have one of the stores and people on the Fair Trade thread said it was unfair.
Bid 2 [2/10] I do like some of the pets but I have one of the stores and people on the Fair Trade thread said it was unfair.
Bid 3 [8/10] I REALLY like the BMD in this trade, but I haven't had imput from the "Is This A Fair Trade?" thread. The BMD is a tier higher, plus the other rares and the staff dog is a nice boost.
Bid 4 [3/10] Not including the christmas tree dog. I think it's fair, but prefer my pets.
=Favorite
(copied from my auction post) The bidding isn't over, but I'd like to know!

I don't know if your Christmas dog has any special demand, but I've seen a rereleased BMD get a Sorbet before. Demand puts BMDs on the mainlist, spot depended on year it was released (many users will overpay a lot for a true date). I'd personally take that one. Get another opinion though.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78957552&userid=944839&signature=sHq_-D-FnyxXtz56EkFn-A

Or

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78951927&userid=944839&signature=NvFlgIn6rfn8s4IgPgyN6w

Or

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78951354&userid=944839&signature=cbTLnJcZDr2g5_NdkBqilQ

Or

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=78967158&userid=944839&signature=q5b_lrUZ9_uiLirHvjIZ3A


Thank you. Two down. Which of these should I accept, assuming I value the zodiac at 2 2009 rares? Could I get better than any of these?

[Puptarts]

Bids:
Bid 1 [2/10] I do like some of the pets but I have one of the stores and people on the Fair Trade thread said it was unfair.
Bid 2 [2/10] I do like some of the pets but I have one of the stores and people on the Fair Trade thread said it was unfair.
Bid 3 [8/10] I REALLY like the BMD in this trade, but I haven't had imput from the "Is This A Fair Trade?" thread. The BMD is a tier higher, plus the other rares and the staff dog is a nice boost.
Bid 4 [3/10] Not including the christmas tree dog. I think it's fair, but prefer my pets.
=Favorite
(copied from my auction post) The bidding isn't over, but I'd like to know!

I don't know if your Christmas dog has any special demand, but I've seen a rereleased BMD get a Sorbet before. Demand puts BMDs on the mainlist, spot depended on year it was released (many users will overpay a lot for a true date). I'd personally take that one. Get another opinion though.

i would take the bmd trade in a heartbeat, both list and demand wise they are greatly overpaying.