The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Nico]

Chocolate Cake Dog or PPS Red X - You already own both in your collection.

Since both are of roughly equal value, which would you prefer to have in your trade stock?

[zippo933]

1) What could I get for a group Store Pets auction? (Eat Me dog, Drink Me dog, Cerberus, Bunny)

2) Clear-eyed galaxy and a pink striped September for my blue sorbet?

3) Clear-eyed galaxy, 2 pink Septembers, 3 October 08 pets (uncommon) and a rare October 08 for my green toxic?

4) Red rose dog, October orange spot, 4 advent dogs, 4 Malk cats, Gold Robot, Valentines b-wolf, Valentines 2nd gen rat, 6 Nick Toxics, uncommon b-wolf, May Shima dog, rose rat and a Halloween 09 'ghost' cat for my green toxic?

5) 4 Nick Toxics and a rare rose rat for my yin-yang green October?

Can at least one of these be answered? I've had these trades sitting in my trading centre for days now.

1) I don't know. I'm holding an auction for the store pets now (not all as one set but separate sets). I haven't gotten many offers yet though. =/

2) I'd accept that but I don't know how fair it is. xD Anyway, it might depend on how badly you need/want the pets being offered and if the sorbet is a double. Personally, I'd accepted it if it was a double but not if they were asking for my only one.

3) I'd be a little unsure about that one. It seems their offering a decent amount of rare/uncommon pets for the Toxic. I guess the questin is: do you have the pets they're offering or do you need/want all of them. Also: do you have a double of the Green Toxic

4) See above. I'd be more inclined to accept the trade offered in question 3 over this one though.

5) I wouldn't accept it. I forget what I traded for mine but it was worth more than what is being offered (though I'm not 100% sure which rat you're referring to.

Anyway, those are my opinions on that. Sorry if I'm not much help. I'm afraid I'm not very good at trading so I mostly go by what I want more than what is rare/common (though I do know the rarities pretty well and at least try to offer fairly and wouldn't accept an extremely unfair trade).

[qhost]

Hehe, thanks :3

All the pets they're asking for are doubles, but I already have all the pets they're offering. So would you say it's unfair?

[Nico]

1) What could I get for a group Store Pets auction? (Eat Me dog, Drink Me dog, Cerberus, Bunny)

2) Clear-eyed galaxy and a pink striped September for my blue sorbet?

3) Clear-eyed galaxy, 2 pink Septembers, 3 October 08 pets (uncommon) and a rare October 08 for my green toxic?

4) Red rose dog, October orange spot, 4 advent dogs, 4 Malk cats, Gold Robot, Valentines b-wolf, Valentines 2nd gen rat, 6 Nick Toxics, uncommon b-wolf, May Shima dog, rose rat and a Halloween 09 'ghost' cat for my green toxic?

5) 4 Nick Toxics and a rare rose rat for my yin-yang green October?

Can at least one of these be answered? I've had these trades sitting in my trading centre for days now.

1. There are a few complete Store Pets auctions, in your shoes, I would look to see what others had offered on them.

2. Sounds reasonable to me, if I needed it I would accept, if not I could afford to haggle some.

3 & 4 For green toxic, I prefer offer 3, others my feel differently.

5. Rare rose rat would make that trade worth it to me, the toxics are just filler.

[Bethykins46]

I am considering auctioning my purple sortic, how much is it worth?

[qhost]

1. There are a few complete Store Pets auctions, in your shoes, I would look to see what others had offered on them.

2. Sounds reasonable to me, if I needed it I would accept, if not I could afford to haggle some.

3 & 4 For green toxic, I prefer offer 3, others my feel differently.

5. Rare rose rat would make that trade worth it to me, the toxics are just filler.

Okay, thanks :3

[calistaria]

My side: Cerberus, Drink Me Dog, Eat Me Dog, January Sorren Pink Birthday Dog, April Strawberry Dog, Uncommon February
Their side: Random Malk Rock, Halloween 09 PPS, Three Very Common 2nd Gens

EDIT: We have been sending this trade back and forth 14 times now, so i kinda need help fast ^^

[Tif + Jo]

My side: Cerberus, Drink Me Dog, Eat Me Dog, January Sorren Pink Birthday Dog, April Strawberry Dog, Uncommon February
Their side: Random Malk Rock, Halloween 09 PPS, Three Very Common 2nd Gens

EDIT: We have been sending this trade back and forth 14 times now, so i kinda need help fast ^^

It's pretty much even, but if you want to knock something off on your side it''s either any one of the shop pets.

[calistaria]

Thanks! I figured ouy that the rock is going to be/is very rare.

[DisabledLlama]

I am considering auctioning my purple sortic, how much is it worth?

Purple Sortic or purple Toxic?

Sortic:


Toxic: