The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Zock the Sock]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111554286&userid=393906&signature=uTajB6-ZxL_lO3WJj8bybg heyy is this fair? tysm in advance !

[bookshelf]

desperately in need of assistance with these trades, i have no idea and hate leaving them hanging


https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111549252&userid=655907&signature=OzrNdd2sV7DSAMjQwjw7Dw

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111553722&userid=655907&signature=WvOIoJJCpTgB3cdHVE7Txw

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111555738&userid=655907&signature=RF8WtdokyxHp3s-ivKpwAw

thank u in advance for any help ! pls lol

for the 1st trade everything on their side except the rainbow draft and 09 vr are overpay rarity-wise, but your pets do have better demand so their extras might fill the gap? not aware of any insane demand on your pets but double check
i think 2nd trade looks unfair to you as your ferret and lion pps are worth 1.5 ma (15 old rares) together plus you have two more valuables on your side and their side does not add up to that as they are offering 2 tier 7s, 1 tier 8, and a normal old vr (total 13-15 old rares)
3rd trade looks fair as both pets are valued at 1 ma

[onion]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111550638&userid=958475&signature=49HKlphdLXtECLPQvBvLJA
• Pretty sure they meant to overpay but, I dunno. I'm pretty bad at grasping these concepts when it comes to high demand pets with overpay offers. The pet on my side is a high demand pet as far as I'm aware so, that's why I priced it so high. If I'm wrong or got it mixed up with another high demand pet, please let me know that too! ^_^ Thank you!

bumping as im the one on the paying side of the trade! i actually have no idea how much the pet is worth or if im overpaying, so i def didnt mean to haha! was just trying to get an even trade. :) thanks yall!

[test.tube.bunny]

is this a fair trade? its for the white lolita
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111556165&userid=916513&signature=KIdnzs_udX1-El37vwum6g

[Animooser]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111552684&userid=329114&signature=-8KgItTaAh8QahrXo818tQ

Hey yall, was wondering if someone could give their opinion on this trade.
I don't typically trade dogs for different breeds but wasn't sure about the demand on these guys. Any help would be appreciated :>

hoping for an opinion on this one still

[Jaybat]

I definitely need help with this trade: trades/viewtrade.php?id=111423703&userid=191502&signature=owW45NrUfbAVhyuA3RMXOg . I'm not sure how much the items are worth.

The trick or treat item to the collar are all 1-2 old rares since these were 2009. Generally I haven't been trading any items from 09 as uncommon so I'd say they are overpaying.

Thank you!

I also got this trade, which includes 3 of the same pets, but the rarities are different.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111444222&userid=191502&signature=PeVIr9JjFrPNZZoTcl84qg
Does anyone have an opinion on which is the better offer? (first trade is here: trades/viewtrade.php?id=111423703&userid=191502&signature=owW45NrUfbAVhyuA3RMXOg )

[Elwynie]

Trade Link
Would this be fair? thank you to those who help(:

grubbs

[angst]

is this a fair trade? its for the white lolita
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111556165&userid=916513&signature=KIdnzs_udX1-El37vwum6g

I think you might be slightly over depending on how they value your TD! If they value it pretty lightly you're about .25non over if they value it normally than it seems like a pretty fair trade.

[OreozHere]

Trade Link
Would this be fair? thank you to those who help(:

grubbs

dark gsd (littermate) is worth about double its rarity worth (1 ma instead of 0.5) so for light gsd lets say it's worth 0.5 ma instead of .25
using this logic your er rat would be a fair swap (albeit rat demand is low) and the rest would be overpay

[ROX.mp4]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111556265&userid=1045569&signature=Sv8SjsNMUOXOOpNOCAKWzw
how is this? ty!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111556236&userid=1045569&signature=XApXwydc9HkJRT9RUTNIlw
also any help with this one too!