The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Aloaei]

So i traded my Blue Rose 08 which said the Rarity: Rare for a Three Headed Dog sorry forgot what they are called. Im hoping it was a good trade. Please tell me i already asked but just got one answer and i would like a few more thanks

[Minimanta]

Is this a fair trade? If not who is getting the better deal?

My side: September cake dog, light leopard dog and hyena bunny
Their side: September X PPS, february green pastel dog, Malk wind cat and a pink heart bunny

So what do you think?

[Fussylou]

Okay I am looking for a Bernes Mountain dog so I have been building up a group to trade for one and I was woundering if the group is good enough post a topic saying I am looking for one or if I need to build it up some more, if it is to much (which I don't think there is such a thing)...

This is what I have so far in the group I am looking to trade of the BMD http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... 8280&go=Go

[LegionWolf]

What I'd be giving - Grey and Green Malk Dragons
What I'd be receiving - Cerberus, Drink-me Dog, Starry Malk Owl, Uncommon Oct. 09 Dog.

[Atwood]

Capri - I think the Sunbun is worth around an uncommon October/September, but don't quote me on that. Unfortunately, I'm pretty sure it's nowhere near a Galaxy.

akebai - the Blue Oct Moon is worth a fair bit more than the Sortic; a couple more uncommon '09s to the Sortic side would probably even it up.

coolpup101 - that sounds reasonable, though it might have been a slightly better deal for the other person than for you.

Minimanta - I think the cake dog is about equal to the PPS, and those bunnies are the same rarity as far as I know, but the Light Leopard is probably worth a bit more than the cat and Green Pastel. It looks about even, but there might need to be a little more on their side to even it out (maybe a somewhat uncommon '09).

Fussylou - I actually think you should take most of the pets out of the group, since a lot of them would be viewed as just 'filler' and of little actual value, like the 2nd Gens. I would keep in the two non-2nd Gens from October, the Valentine Cat, the White Sortic, the Green Sparkle, the Blue Roan, and anything else that's listed as Uncommon or better, and take out anything that's listed as Very common or Common, including the bettas and most of the horses. Quality matters far more than quantity, so it's better to have a smaller group of only good pets than a large one with lots of filler pets.

LegionWolf - that's probably a good trade for you, but I'm not certain, so you should probably try to get a second opinion.

[Delete.]

Would all four store Pets and some Pets from this group http://www.chickensmoothie.com/accounts ... erid=15660 be worth a Clear Eyed Galaxy?

[zippo933]

My Side: Skeleton Bunny
Their Side: this stuff

This is the original trade I sent. I figured it was okay since I had extra Skeleton bunnies to trade. SO maybe it wasn't as fair as it could have been (afterall, 8 sets of those wings are almost equal to what the bunny costs in the CS Store).

HOWEVER

The person I was trading with edited out 2 sets of wings AND wanted a Cerberus as well as the Skele Bun.

That is an unfair trade right?

[calistaria]

My Side: Skeleton Bunny
Their Side: this stuff

This is the original trade I sent. I figured it was okay since I had extra Skeleton bunnies to trade. SO maybe it wasn't as fair as it could have been (afterall, 8 sets of those wings are almost equal to what the bunny costs in the CS Store).

HOWEVER

The person I was trading with edited out 2 sets of wings AND wanted a Cerberus as well as the Skele Bun.

That is an unfair trade right?

Absolutely unfair! A skelly bunny AND a cerberus? Never!

[zippo933]

Thank you Castro. That's what I thought but apparently the person I was attempting to trade with didn't agree. I figured I'd better get a second opinion in case I was going crazy or something. xD

[qhost]

1) What could I get for a group Store Pets auction? (Eat Me dog, Drink Me dog, Cerberus, Bunny)

2) Clear-eyed galaxy and a pink striped September for my blue sorbet?

3) Clear-eyed galaxy, 2 pink Septembers, 3 October 08 pets (uncommon) and a rare October 08 for my green toxic?

4) Red rose dog, October orange spot, 4 advent dogs, 4 Malk cats, Gold Robot, Valentines b-wolf, Valentines 2nd gen rat, 6 Nick Toxics, uncommon b-wolf, May Shima dog, rose rat and a Halloween 09 'ghost' cat for my green toxic?

5) 4 Nick Toxics and a rare rose rat for my yin-yang green October?

Can at least one of these be answered? I've had these trades sitting in my trading centre for days now.