The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Decca]

How's this?

[joba]

is this fair? if not, what should they add?
thank you in advance! (:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... bwzb3KCBTw

[Silverstar]

is this fair? and also what is each of these store pets worth? an 09 rare?

a '14 store pet is worth a late '09 rare, so fair.

[Joof]

is this fair? and also what is each of these store pets worth? an 09 rare?

a '14 store pet is worth about a late 09 rare. your cat is late 09 so it's a fair trade (:

is this fair? if not, what should they add?
thank you in advance! (:
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... bwzb3KCBTw

the target dog is worth 2 mid advents and 2 09 rares. the nick cake dog is a mid advent and 6-8 09 rares add up to another mid advent. depending on if you value a mid advent at 6, 7 or 8 09 rares, they are overpaying either by 1,2 or 3 09 rares and the uncommon cat (:

[marshsiren]

i just got this trade from a lovely person and was wondering if it was fair. If the trade isn't fair what needs to be add/removed?(includes items)
Here is the trade c:
-anyways have a lovely day

[LemonadeQueen]

Was this fair? Tysm! <3 (Was that the Blue Rose Dog from the September List? I'm not sure

[timothee]

Was this fair? Tysm! <3 (Was that the Blue Rose Dog from the September List? I'm not sure

Very unfair to them. the blue rose alone would be extreme overpay just for the grinner. Not only is it higher on the list, it has better demand.

[Onyx!!]

If i traded my blue rose for a balilisk set what should they add?

[Aphotic]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... KMtdcZMkMw

Would this be fair? I'm not sure how to calculate the difference in rarity based on dates. And are dragons still in high demand? I recall they were very popular when first released.

Wrong link. Make sure to use the [share trade] link, which can be found right on the top of a trade.

Sorry about that! I fixed the link. Thank you for letting me know.

[Joof]

If i traded my blue rose for a balilisk set what should they add?

a blue rose is worth 7 mid advents. the basilisks are 3 low advents or 1.5 mid advents. so basically the'd need to add 5 mid advents in value (red rose tier) plus a couple 09 rares or a floppy pink september tier or something equal in value (: