The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[abbie.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68923695&userid=863256&signature=HzUfAvfbSJnltRYcWyhvhg
With demand, what would need to be added to make it fair? I'm the List side!

[LovelyRita]

Was this a good trade to accept? I've already accpted I just wanna make sure I made the right decision

[meged321]

Is this fair? Thank you in advance
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... r0j_ACG7uA

[Banana.]

Is this bid fair? x

And would this rat be hard to trade off? This is another bid I got and I know it’s overpay but the only thing keeping me from accepting is the rat.
x

[киσ¢кσυт]

I know this is overpay rarity-wise. But how about demand wise? boop

Honeslty i dont think its fair, the rarity makes no sense, if it was arounda 2010-2009 rare i would think it would be around fair, but that to me feels like there sending you forward 4 more years. Its rare to find 2008 pets in my opinion. Anyways i hope this helped

[ThunderCedar]

Is this fair? Thank you in advance
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... r0j_ACG7uA

candycane horse is worth 4-5 09 rares
the green fronted holly is worth 10 09 rares. this is unfair to you, demand and rarity wise.

[HeavenlyAura]

Is a Red Fronted Holly + a 2013 Pink Alpaca Store Pet
fair for an August PPS?


Demand wise only please.

[ThunderCedar]

Is a Red Fronted Holly + a 2013 Pink Alpaca Store Pet
fair for an August PPS?


Demand wise only please.

demand wise, the august pps can go for higher prices than this depending on the user you're trading. I've seen it easily go for Septembers in the past.

I know this is overpay rarity-wise. But how about demand wise? boop

Honeslty i dont think its fair, the rarity makes no sense, if it was arounda 2010-2009 rare i would think it would be around fair, but that to me feels like there sending you forward 4 more years. Its rare to find 2008 pets in my opinion. Anyways i hope this helped

please don't give false advice. You could accidentally make someone reject a good trade, or accept a bad one. the blood pps is worth 8 mid advents, the angel advent is worth 7 mid advents. this is unfair to the blood pps.

[LovelyRita]

Was this a good trade to accept? I've already accpted I just wanna make sure I made the right decision

[Banana.]

Is this bid fair? x

And would this rat be hard to trade off? This is another bid I got and I know it’s overpay but the only thing keeping me from accepting is the rat.
x