The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Puptarts]

Thoughts?? trades/viewtrade.php?id=78967745&userid=889555&signature=tPcI3XX9dwLikmmK__I06w

valuing the td ba at a non and the cerb at 3 nons this makes your side 4.5 nons tops.. i wouldn't send this trade personally but rarity wise it's extremely unfair to them as the sunjewel is worth 5 nons and you are offering some september lists and a little over a sorbet.

[iconerfatty]

Thoughts?? trades/viewtrade.php?id=78967745&userid=889555&signature=tPcI3XX9dwLikmmK__I06w

valuing the td ba at a non and the cerb at 3 nons this makes your side 4.5 nons tops.. i wouldn't send this trade personally but rarity wise it's extremely unfair to them as the sunjewel is worth 5 nons and you are offering some september lists and a little over a sorbet.

Alright, second opinion? Is the sun jewel hard to trade off?

[Xeroxoe]

Thoughts? xxx
Thank you!

[nobxdy]

Thoughts? xxx
Thank you!

unfair to you, the UR Malk is on the Non tier. Their side doesn't add up to a Non.

[Astellia]

I'm hosting an auction and these are the bids so far. I just need some second opinions. Which one seems the most fair? I like bids 5, 6, & 9. 9 is leading. The auction ends today and I REALLY need advice. I've gotten a couple opinions and I would just like a couple more! I'll be ending it when I get home this afternoon.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11

9. is about fair, the c$ makes it overpay so i would accept that one
(not going through all those trades, i'm sorry)

I was thinking the same thing. And don't worry about going through all of the trades, I'm mostly concerned about 5, 6, & 9. Thank you! Anyone else?

[ordinary people]

Are any of these fair and which one you would personally accept? Thanks c:

One
Two

Anybody? c:

[nobxdy]

Are These Fair?
1. trades/viewtrade.php?id=78968479&userid=919360&signature=hlFstacP1_cMMMbV7t8Vcg
2. trades/viewtrade.php?id=78978472&userid=919360&signature=YIuJJj5y79cYDlvJ_BS7Jw

They're both overpaying considering your store pet is only worth an early-mid '10 rare (extended into 2018). It's up to you which one you would rather take.

I'm hosting an auction and these are the bids so far. I just need some second opinions. Which one seems the most fair? I like bids 5, 6, & 9. 9 is leading. The auction ends today and I REALLY need advice. I've gotten a couple opinions and I would just like a couple more! I'll be ending it when I get home this afternoon.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11

I was thinking the same thing. And don't worry about going through all of the trades, I'm mostly concerned about 5, 6, & 9. Thank you! Anyone else?

I personally like #6 the most if that helps. Honestly up to you though.

[Astellia]

I'm hosting an auction and these are the bids so far. I just need some second opinions. Which one seems the most fair? I like bids 5, 6, & 9. 9 is leading. The auction ends today and I REALLY need advice. I've gotten a couple opinions and I would just like a couple more! I'll be ending it when I get home this afternoon.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11

I was thinking the same thing. And don't worry about going through all of the trades, I'm mostly concerned about 5, 6, & 9. Thank you! Anyone else?

I personally like #6 the most if that helps. Honestly up to you though.[/quote]

Curious as to why? Just preference or value?

[nobxdy]

I'm hosting an auction and these are the bids so far. I just need some second opinions. Which one seems the most fair? I like bids 5, 6, & 9. 9 is leading. The auction ends today and I REALLY need advice. I've gotten a couple opinions and I would just like a couple more! I'll be ending it when I get home this afternoon.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11

I personally like #6 the most if that helps. Honestly up to you though.

Curious as to why? Just preference or value?

I just feel like they're offering better pets compared to every other offer you have, and they're over by a '10 rare (since 2016 store pets = late '09 rare). I personally don't like #9 because of the zebra, b-wolf, and C$, though that's just my personal opinion.

[Eckobass101]

Is this okay? xx