The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[sumatra.]

Thoughts on this trade?
I’m unsure what the CEG is also going for currently

Both CEG and Joker trade for a non or more~

I value my joker at 1.5-2 nons. Does the CEG also ever trade for that much? I was told the BEG hardly ever gets over a non, does the CEG have more demand?

[Deity]

This?

completely fair, pps cocoon is tier 5 advent and they all go for 75 C$ according to here
it's up to you whether you take it or not

Thanks! And This?

[Zombilon]

Would you personally accept this?
Just based on demand, needing opinions, no need to calculate fairness. (I love my true-date 7th tiers, but I also love the PPS Dragon Cats, so this is a tough choice).

Personally I wouldn't accept, if the PPS dragon cat traded for tier 7s, they would have set it offering the cats alone, at least that'd be my thinking if I got the trade. The two tier 2 wood dogs are worth 3-4 rares each and so are worth one of the tier 7s. If you're particularly attached to your dogs, perhaps half the pets on both side? 2 of your dogs for 1 of their dark wood dogs and 2 dragon cats?

Thanks, second opinions? ^^

[Corviknight]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73146761&userid=850884&signature=JtD7mfJnrz3LfmMtLacidQ
would this be fair?

[Bloodpaw/Sangre]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=72731379&userid=548495&signature=bjFrMXyWcvcI-O_vupwzZA

How is this demand wise?

[Morƒonica]

I don't know the value of these items, can someone tell me if this is fair or not?

[Jedi Master Lady Ren]

Is This fair?

[Deity]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73146761&userid=850884&signature=JtD7mfJnrz3LfmMtLacidQ
would this be fair?

Their side adds up to a little more than 5 ‘09’s and the Christmas tree dog advent goes for 6-7.

This?

completely fair, pps cocoon is tier 5 advent and they all go for 75 C$ according to here
it's up to you whether you take it or not

Thanks! And This?

[Zombilon]

Would you personally accept this?
Just based on demand, needing opinions, no need to calculate fairness. (I love my true-date 7th tiers, but I also love the PPS Dragon Cats, so this is a tough choice).

Personally I wouldn't accept, if the PPS dragon cat traded for tier 7s, they would have set it offering the cats alone, at least that'd be my thinking if I got the trade. The two tier 2 wood dogs are worth 3-4 rares each and so are worth one of the tier 7s. If you're particularly attached to your dogs, perhaps half the pets on both side? 2 of your dogs for 1 of their dark wood dogs and 2 dragon cats?

Thanks, second opinions? ^^
(I could try editing in two more wood dogs to their side, but I'm afraid it might seem to be too much?)

[sumatra.]

Thoughts on this trade?
I’m unsure what the CEG is also going for currently

Both CEG and Joker trade for a non or more~

second opinion?
valuing my joker @ 1.5-2 nons