The "Is this a fair Trade?" thread.

[Seira3]

MY

light sept leopard, 2x blue/red green oct,
blue x-mas scarf, fox cat, purple and white dog,
green and white dog, pps valentine, valentine grown dog,
black skull malk cat, caramel rat, st pattys dog,
light gear dog, Cs 1st b-day bob tail, st Barnard bunny,
panda pps, zebra pps, grey dragon fly wolf, grown zombie malk horse,
x2 ghost cat, drink me/eat me dog, skull bunny, Cerberus,
green malk spider, ungrown halloween rat, both black rats,
just grown butterwolf, black 2 gen, flame malk horse, red/black/white malk fish,
green/orange butterwolf, flop ear halloween dog, red/black butter wolf,
copper/ green dragons, ghost owl, mummy cat, x3 skull malk fish, light pps oct,
pink/tan moon oct, orange oct spot, red rose dog

for their
sunback july

[Coalchaser]

Them: Non PPS demon winged halloween 09 dog

Me: (They Want) Brown/white cake dog, Hat advent, Valentines PPS, Easter hunt bunny, and the rare green B-woolf



I think thats a bit much, or is it?

That's way too much. xD That dog isn't even close to as rare as the August green butterfly wolf. I would think that it would be fair with just the brown/white cake dog.

[Duani]

Wait, give them the 08 september birthday cake dog?

[Coalchaser]

Wait, give them the 08 september birthday cake dog?

O.o Oh wow, definitely not. I was in a rush when I wrote that, and thought you meant this guy (which, now that I look at it, is brown and tan, not brown and white):

I didn't even think that someone would expect an '08 cake dog for it!
Ack, sorry, I should have read that better...^^"
Every single pet this person wants is too rare for the winged demon.

[Duani]

My fault, I should have been more specific.

[mmmcoffee]

What do you guys think?

My side - Excuse me, I meant, this is what I asked for.
Green Dragon
November Malk wolf pup

Their side - Excuse me, I meant, this is what they requested in return.
January black dog with rainbow stripes
February Malk cat with brown spots
March Seeing Eye Aztec dog
August black wolf with blue markings

[T. Faulkner]

My: Grey malk dragon

for their: Cerberus, Skeleton rabbit, Dark Pink Shima b-wolf, and a fox advent.

I like the person, and would really like to give them the dragon, but I'm saving up for a pet I really want, too- so I need a fair trade. And I'll admit right off the bat- I'm horrible at figuring out values myself. Looking for at least two opinions before I accept.

EDITED: Sorry, had a wrong pet up there that they were offering. ^^;

[iPawki]

I'd say it's fair. I got a December '08 dogs and two uncommon Januarys for mine, and I thought that it was pretty fair.

[T. Faulkner]

I'd say it's fair. I got a December '08 dogs and two uncommon Januarys for mine, and I thought that it was pretty fair.

I'm not certain but I'm assuming this is directed at mine. ^^; If it is, thanks, Lionpaw.

Any second opinions before I accept it?

[iPawki]

Yes it is.