The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[the]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79543029&userid=959439&signature=k_TtjX8l2j4fWjpli8esHQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79541691&userid=959439&signature=v6sBt4YU1lz6zmzfTs-8qQ

Sorry :) These fair

First trade is unfair to them. A '16 store pet is worth a late rare '09 and your side doesn't add up to that. Second trade is unfair to them as well, 5 store pets '16 = 5 rares '09. Your dog is worth 2.

[critic-burnt]

fair? i'm not really sure how much c$ is worth

[SomethingFishy~]

Click here
Hello! What would make this a fair trade?
Thanks in advance!

[Dollteeths]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79544308&userid=851953&signature=CAiVsLM7M3a9rN-jLuqIOw

this fair?

[Kitkat2716]

Help on this trade is greatly appreciated. Thank you

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79538976&userid=469345&signature=Y9wJppyZN4R5dinPx0VxYw

[Kittyness]

What do you think? I'm considering

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79530498&userid=451951&signature=YfOSupAxzGc1rlAcGi-4xQ

[demoo]

is this fair?
thank you <3

(i'd like another opinion, because thats what was suggested lol)
aalso is this other one fair? lol

and this ):
(yes, all three, i'm horrible at trades and idk why i'm getting so many ??)

[chaotic creativity]

Would a holly fox cat + holly fox dog = wolf pps?
How about holly fox cat + holly fox dog + shima = wolf pps?

[bailey.exe]

Edit;; If anyone has been posting for a while and hasn’t been responded to: feel free to PM me and I’ll gladly help you if I am able. Keep in mind I’m not good at item trades.

How about this trade for my lioness???
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79541823&userid=893005&signature=g8gQ8-5UC9J2nQ5fkSd8Eg
And
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79540089&userid=893005&signature=_U1mzwFo5qNZWnyzE14GwA
Plus this one
trades/viewtrade.php?id=79541159&userid=893005&signature=rcHAFLBuck2lzN_kbypSaA

Help please!!!

.

Hi there!
Your lioness is worth 2 2012 rares.
I’ll try to make everything in increments of 09 rares.

First trade:
Your lioness is from July of 2012. Their VR Dog is a rerelease from 2008 and from what I’ve read a 2008 VR is worth 4 09’ rares. They are overpaying already because their VR is much older. Not to mention they have added in three 2019 store pets. Each of these pets it’s worth a late 2010 rare from what I’ve heard.
Also, if you still follow the rares list, their 08 dog is a Tier 5 Advent. This makes it worth 6-7 09’ rares. (This is only applicable to those who follow the list.)

If you use the list their side is worth: 7-8 09’ rares, and a couple of commons
If you don’t use the list their side is worth: 5 09’ rares, and a couple of commons
Either way, they are overpaying big time.

Second trade:
Once again your lioness is from July of 2012. Their VR Dog is from 2009. From what I’ve heard an 09’ VR is worth 2 09’ rares. Also they have 6 09’ rares.

Their side is worth: 8 09’ rares.
Once again, they are overpaying.

Third trade:
As for this one I’m unsure as I’m not good at item trading. Feel free to repost this one for help.

If you use the list you might prefer the first trade but they are essentially worth the same.

Feel free to give a second opinion, my insight might be different to someone else’s.

[FireWolf52]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79544720&userid=952637&signature=oJxa8qfvR-C-3_YrLHhpLw

What do you think about this... I’m hesitant I don’t really like this trade but...