Closed

[milk69]

I know rarity wise it's overpay on their side, but I was wondering if this is fair demand wise? How much does the UR cucumber go for usually? Thank you! <3

[LuckyHeart]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Nyr2T8ASZw

Was this trade fair? Thanks for any advice <3

Unfair to them, the blood pps, dark gray tag husky, and blue swirl are all on the list (pps on september, other 2 on advent)

[Kitkat2716]

Need help for two trades please!:
Trade 1
Trade 2

Which one of these trade would be fair to me? (Please consider Demands too c:)

The one with the rat is unfair to you by rarity and demand.

The second one would be a better offer considering the demand of the zodiacs. The quantity is nice too but it's still super unfair to you demand wise.

I suggest getting another opinion though.

[recherché.]

Thoughts? What needs to be added? Thanks in advance!

[whim]

Is this any fair?

Thanks in advance!

[LuckyHeart]

Is this any fair?

Thanks in advance!

Unfair to your; I believe those store pets are worth late 2009 rares each, so their 2 2012 rares only equal a 2011 one.

[future violents]

Is this any fair?

Thanks in advance!

Unfair to your; I believe those store pets are worth late 2009 rares each, so their 2 2012 rares only equal a 2011 one.

The 2014 store pet is worth an early '10 rare, though it's still unfair. Their side needs to add an '11 rare.

[LuckyHeart]

Is this any fair?

Thanks in advance!

Unfair to your; I believe those store pets are worth late 2009 rares each, so their 2 2012 rares only equal a 2011 one.

The 2014 store pet is worth an early '10 rare, though it's still unfair. Their side needs to add an '11 rare.

ah, my bad I get the store pet values mixed up xD

[Eyulf]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=53043543&userid=99521&signature=UsypCMO2Nzs7kPRrfMMuQg
Also with the Dark wood dog (I'm yet to edit them in) is the '08 Halo worth a low September list, pocky worth late '09 R/VR, and Malk Mutant Plush worth about a late '09 R. Is the Target dog fair for the dog and items? and what is the Target dogs popularity?
Thank you. This is a bid offer for my Auction.

[ImThatRogue]

X
I'm fairly sure this isn't fair to me, but how much do they need to add to make it fair? Thanks!

Also this...is it fair?

Yes, it's unfair to you. Their side adds up to a bit less than 4 mid advents, and your UR Apple is worth roughly 15 mid advents, so they'd have to add roughly a low mainlist in order for this to be fair.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Nyr2T8ASZw

Was this trade fair? Thanks for any advice <3

This was quite unfair to them. The Cheshire cat is technically worth only a mid/early '09 rare, but it tends to go for more due to its demand. However, even taking into account the Cheshire's demand, that's some huge overpay... Their side adds up to be worth a bit more than a low mainlist. That's worth a little over 76x the value of the Cheshire cat!

Need help for two trades please!:
Trade 1
Trade 2

Which one of these trade would be fair to me? (Please consider Demands too c:)

The one with the rat is unfair to you by rarity and demand.

The second one would be a better offer considering the demand of the zodiacs. The quantity is nice too but it's still super unfair to you demand wise.

I suggest getting another opinion though.

1. Without taking into account any demand, this is slightly unfair to them (by a '10 rare). Their side adds up to be worth a scarf pps, and your side adds up to be worth just a '10 rare less than a scarf pps. However, their zodiac dogs do seem to have good demand and often go for overpay. Not sure what the demand of the lists are... I believe they seem to have average demand? May want another opinion on this, just to make sure.

2. Actually, this is technically unfair to them. Their lime ice rat is a mid September list pet worth about 6-7 mid advents. Your side is worth a bit less than half of that. However, rats do tend to have bad demand, and can be fairly difficult to trade away fairly.

Thoughts? What needs to be added? Thanks in advance!

This is unfair to them. The gap between your red toxic and their blue sorbet is a balloon dog.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=53043543&userid=99521&signature=UsypCMO2Nzs7kPRrfMMuQg
Also with the Dark wood dog (I'm yet to edit them in) is the '08 Halo worth a low September list, pocky worth late '09 R/VR, and Malk Mutant Plush worth about a late '09 R. Is the Target dog fair for the dog and items? and what is the Target dogs popularity?
Thank you. This is a bid offer for my Auction.

This is unfair to you. Just your halo, worth a low September list, would be fair enough for their target dog.