The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Screechy]

This for every pet and item from the Halloween 2012 event
Thanks!
-Screechy

[Guest]

Fair?

[Umbrellas]

Fair?

unfair to them ^^

[Guest]

Fair?

unfair to them ^^

Alright, thank you Twisted. Another opinion please?

[Isilcu]

What is the demand like for these pets they're offering? Would I be better off keeping the Halloween Cat?

First Trade
Second Trade

Thank you for any help! ^^

I'd keep the Halloween Cat both trades
First is unfair to you
the second is okay but Grinners are hard to trade off

Thank you so much!

[Demonking Urizen]

I asked because I want to trade this item:



The item guide says it is worth a late '09 uncommon.
So ... could I try to offer on a Halloween '10 rare? Or would it be unfair?

[Apocolyptic Chaos]

Fair?

unfair to them ^^

Alright, thank you Twisted. Another opinion please?

Unfair to them c:

[Nari UwU]

What have ye to say of this?
Its an auction bid, so I'd like to know how fair, what could be improved, etc.

Edit:This is another bid

Edit:
And another. Which is better, demand/rarity wise?

[c h r i s t m a s]

What have ye to say of this?
Its an auction bid, so I'd like to know how fair, what could be improved, etc.

Edit:This is another bid

Edit:
And another. Which is better, demand/rarity wise?

i would say the second is best ^^

[Meraa]

Trade I got for last store dogs

Please can anyone help me if I should consider this trade?

Since I'm collecting dogs none of those pets is adding anything to my collection and most of them I don't even want. Would I get more of taking that trade and trading away what I got (will that be easy for rare dogs?) or shall I cancel and keep them to trade for dogs directly?

Unfair to them
2012 store pet = 2010 rare

Thank you. Maybe another opionion on how popular those rares are and if it's somewhat easy to trade them away?