The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Rahel:)]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83910660&userid=727649&signature=8b_Qqd0CbZB-RPRDNBh_Jg

Can anyone help me out with this item trade? I think it is a good offer, but I'm not 100% sure..

[itsliza]

Or this one? Im not good with bulk trades.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83910308&userid=772106&signature=2HFtOI6Tio8cpD7jT9C9Uw

[defectedcat]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83907485&userid=667317&signature=lW7gaBSaE5fRHuyv_heH2w

is this fair for a non?

[Mochichimchim]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83909768&userid=887658&signature=1aaPwS89mafauorRyM9FDw

here's the link. is this fair or should I add 1k $CS?

[SeaCrest]

Or this one? Im not good with bulk trades.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83910308&userid=772106&signature=2HFtOI6Tio8cpD7jT9C9Uw

Unfair to the bottom. The top doesn't fully cover a '13 uncommon by itself, nevermind all the additional pets they want.

[greenbunny1998]

Is this trade fair for my card dogs?

Thank you.

They are offering 3 09 rares worth + some uncommons and newer rares not mentioned because they don’t add up to much
Both of your dogs are worth 2 ‘09 rares and 1 ‘10 rare each as they are from Nov 2008. They need to add about 2 ‘09 rares to be fair rarity wise.

Personal opinion here: Demand wise you could get way more. (I personally demand value those dogs at 3-4 ‘09 rares each as that is what I personally would be willing to pay for them. Others may not, that so, demand is not set for them.)

Thank you so much, they have edited their trade to this, thank you so much.

[Mochichimchim]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83907485&userid=667317&signature=lW7gaBSaE5fRHuyv_heH2w

is this fair for a non?

Thats unfair on the top. There are too many lists offered. A non isnt worth that much

[Jiloon]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83910660&userid=727649&signature=8b_Qqd0CbZB-RPRDNBh_Jg

Can anyone help me out with this item trade? I think it is a good offer, but I'm not 100% sure..

They're overpaying big time! The butterfly alone would technically be fair, add a rat to make up for a little demand difference, but the other rats and other old rare are overpay c; None of those items are very rare, most are worth uncommons from their respective years, and the griffin set is just a store set!

[JJdiner]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83907485&userid=667317&signature=lW7gaBSaE5fRHuyv_heH2w

is this fair for a non?

Thats unfair on the top. There are too many lists offered. A non isnt worth that much

i disagree, it is very unfair to the non, the omgsr rat gets a sorb at most which is rather hard to do, and the other lists are low, aside from the ice one, which is also a rat and doesn't get its worth either. quantity of random 09 rares doesn't add up for the worth of the non which would technically be worth 252ma or 1512-2016 09s, though thats absolutely absurd and would probably go for a couple hundred, its still technical. basically unfair to the non

[GreenteaLatte]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83907485&userid=667317&signature=lW7gaBSaE5fRHuyv_heH2w

is this fair for a non?

Thats unfair on the top. There are too many lists offered. A non isnt worth that much

I'd disagree. It's very unfair to the bottom. The OMGSR rat can go for a sorb or less and the rest of the pets don't add up to a sorb. I only see 2 other lists (both september) from the top other than the omgsr rat. However bulk does have its own demand. It just depends on which side you prefer more. Bulk or quality.