The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[kököchin]

would a blue rose be a fair 1:1 swap for a red rose with current demand? thank you for any/all responses <3

[Neonrift]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92051198&userid=707020&signature=VknBkhA8D5zpjysL7xxi9w anyone have any ideas on this?

[3ds]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92051060&userid=966372&signature=vMBRd_6v-wo94LpIHgAL9Q

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92051100&userid=966372&signature=Z4cvbvLmq18_sls3nlV5Ig ?

1st trade:
The dog you have is called the Blue Snowflake/Flower Advent, by this list (which I highly recommend), it is a mid advent list, which is worth 6-9 09 rares. I'd personally accept this if you're looking to go off the list (going off the list = not trading for other list pets) / some other reason !

The 3 dalmations = 3 09's
The 2020 storepets (late 10' rare) collected together = 4 09's (valuing 2 2010's at 1 09' here)
The pencil dog = 09'

So it adds up to 8 09's! - So again, I'd personally accept since it is fair to you & you'd have a lot of storepets aha.

2nd trade:
Valuing 2 2010's at 1 09 again, this is fair to you, but it does include horses & no 09's or storepets like the first,
so it's totally up to you ( which side of pets you want ) !

thank you so very much!

[crucifying.]

Is this fair? I’m not exactly sure what the Dogtag goes for these day.

Tysm for any help <3

valuing dogtag at 1.5-2.

punk is .5
angel advent is 3MAs (about .25)
nonswirl is 1
mustard husky is 1MA

your side would be 1.75 & 1 MA. if you value dogtag at 1.5, it’s unfair to you by .25 & 1MA. if you value it at 2, you’re under by about 2-3 MAs.

[beestie]

some folks have edited their bids, so i'd like a revaluation of the values! a quick answer would be great, please.

x / x / x

and there's these two by the same person.

x / x

i'd really appreciate some help with these bids!

[ηαтαlιє]

Hey guys :3

Is this fair? It seems to me both aren´t on the list.

Thank you :)

[Panda-Love-100]

is this trade fair?

[Osborn]

trade
i'm hesitant because my lists aren't necessarily bad demand and the patchwork is a dreamie but, how fair is this?

[☠puppy gutz!☠]

xxx is this fair? ty in advance!

[ThunderCedar]

is this trade fair?

It is unfair to them.

Their items are from 2015 (Eyes) and 2016 (Blue Orbit items).
Your side's are from 2018 (shibe kigurumi) and 2019 (santa hat wig) The rest are free from the store (no real worth).
Items are usually valued at a common/uncommon from their year.

Valuing them at uncommon each,
Your side is worth about a 2017 uncommon.
Theirs is worth about a 2014 uncommon.