The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Kirra888]

Sorry haha
heres the right link
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87516587&userid=822031&signature=fhkR8b33PNhjqcSv2vLocA

[♡HappyAlpaca♡]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=87495509&userid=983291&signature=SmXMK2s7RuLHMyNh4ZDFPA

Is this fair?

[Guest]

Sorry haha
heres the right link
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87516587&userid=822031&signature=fhkR8b33PNhjqcSv2vLocA

On terms of worth, it's a fair swap as they're both early 2009 pets! However, warriors cats do have superior demand and value compared to butterfly wolves; they can fetch double their worth because they're a demanding specie and valued highly by many.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=87495509&userid=983291&signature=SmXMK2s7RuLHMyNh4ZDFPA

Is this fair?

No, here's why: click

I'll pay/ask for more or less depending on personal preference.

'08 uncommon I personally value as 10 C$
'09 uncommon I personally value as 8-10 C$
'10 uncommon I personally value as 6-8 C$
'11 uncommon I personally value as 5-6 C$
'12 uncommon I personally value as 4-5 C$
'13 uncommon I personally value as 3-4 C$
'14 uncommon I personally value as 3 C$
'15 uncommon I personally value as 2.5 C$
'16 uncommon I personally value at 2 C$
17 uncommon I personally value at 1.5-2 C$
'18 uncommon I personally value at 1-1.5 C$
'19 uncommon I personally value at 1 C$
‘20 uncommon I personally value at .5

[Fallenleaf]

Sorry haha
heres the right link
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87516587&userid=822031&signature=fhkR8b33PNhjqcSv2vLocA

Rarity wise/with worth you would have been over with the date of your pet because of the extended release of warriors. But with demand you'd be "under", warrior cats can easily get 2 '09 rares for them and you'd need to add, but it just depends on how you value warriors. I trade 2 '09 rares commonly for rare warriors and the VR ones can fetch even more (with demand)

Ah new thread and I needed to post

[GL1TZY]

Can you help me and tell me what one of these are fairrelevant and not trades/viewtrade.php?id=87509244&userid=978537&signature=gduk2nLABHttTCmSr6hPOA
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87509286&userid=978537&signature=0H0AJGqY9YTqMsxve0RARA
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87509406&userid=978537&signature=MBiaU8iOymmJFmqB_A1b_A
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87509322&userid=978537&signature=KKTAp-ISLjZvTZtaFI6kBQ

[Guest]

Can you help me and tell me what one of these are fairrelevant and not trades/viewtrade.php?id=87509244&userid=978537&signature=gduk2nLABHttTCmSr6hPOA
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87509286&userid=978537&signature=0H0AJGqY9YTqMsxve0RARA
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87509406&userid=978537&signature=MBiaU8iOymmJFmqB_A1b_A
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87509322&userid=978537&signature=KKTAp-ISLjZvTZtaFI6kBQ

The first trade is technically fair on terms of worth, but the Zodiac dog is also a demanding pet and easily fetches 100-150 C$
The zodiac dog can fetch double its worth, aka a 2009 rare or 2 2010 rares. This makes the second trade over as the 2009 rare dog should be enough.
The last trade is worth the most as it can fetch 2 2009 rares, that's triple the worth of the Zodiac dog and I would personally take that trade. If you follow the 2:1 rule, the 2019 store pet is worth a 2010 rare, 2 2010 rares = 1 2009 rare or 1 2010 VR, making their side over.

[KathrynKat]

I'm not sure when 2+ store pets for another is fair and unfair.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87516453&userid=245230&signature=ekSLKHzeV1L17zvBNYgzMA
Thanks to any help

[AustrianAce]

would this be fair? <--item trade

[grey matter]

how fair is this? trades/viewtrade.php?id=87516766&userid=953222&signature=VxExg5Fc65NbHRYOlKTScA

[Guest]

I'm not sure when 2+ store pets for another is fair and unfair.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=87516453&userid=245230&signature=ekSLKHzeV1L17zvBNYgzMA
Thanks to any help

A 2014 store pet goes for 2 2009 rares, while a 2015 store pet goes for 1 early 2009 rare

how fair is this? trades/viewtrade.php?id=87516766&userid=953222&signature=VxExg5Fc65NbHRYOlKTScA

A 2014 store pet is worth 2 2009 rares, this would be unfair for you.
Their side is worth:
5 2020 rares OR 2 2020 VR's + 1 2020 rare
1 2019 uncommon
1 2019 common