The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[sasha.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... fSNm9rW6Wg

Is this fair? If not, what on my side should be taken off/added?

[Joof]

UR Foal+Cake dog=What tier main list?

A cake dog is not enough to jump up a tier from the ur foal. the ur foal side would need to add about a balloon dog plus two mid advents to equal the next higher tier: spotted tribal (:

[raccoon bandit]

help?
Was sent as a suggestion with no message so idk which side they want me to adjust and I'm awful at demand, but I do know that the blue rose has a high demand and I'm not sure about the bwolf. Any and all opinions are appreciated! <3

[jade,]

this?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZyHDMP5oGQ

[Lexiloofroo7]

So.. not too happy with this trade. I really love my Shima, so this had better be a REALLY good trade.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vYjhwIc_TQ

[Jiloon]

fair? how good is the demand for basilisks?

It's okay, but it doesn't come even close to a tier 7 Advent c;

[toonie]

Is this fair?

[WesternWolf2528]

UR Foal+Cake dog=What tier main list?

A cake dog is not enough to jump up a tier from the ur foal. the ur foal side would need to add about a balloon dog plus two mid advents to equal the next higher tier: spotted tribal (:

Rarity wise it takes a UR Foal + Line Tribal to make the next tier up, but of course if you consider the demand of the UR Foal it could go for a Spotted Tribal on it's own, possibly more.

[SHARKGVTS]

X

How is this?

This is a big risk
if the dog grows into a sunjewel, then they'll only be overpaying by a little bit
If the dog turns into a non, then it'll definitely be unfair to you by a bit

I wouldn't take it personally

[Shadow2204]

Fair? I got 2 offers for my zonkey:

Ur lion+ (Bid 1)

Ur fox + (Bid 2)

Bid 3: UR foods

Please help! Which is fair? Both rarity and demand. Which one should i accept or should i decline all of them?

Zonkey is going for 1-2 nons.
1. Blue dragon pps goes for sorbets. So their side is worth a UR Aussie + green toxic (1 non + 1 sorb + 1 green toxic) Which is fair since it's between the 1-2 nons of value.
2. Depends on how you value the UR Fox. It's a bit too early to determine what it's going for right now. But the trade would only be fair if you value the UR fox as at least a non.
3. UR banana = 2 nons + green toxic. UR cucumber = 2 nons + green toxic. Their side is worth 4 nons + a sorbet. With demand, the banana goes for almost fair trades so i'll value it as 2 nons. UR cucumber goes for a non. So demand wise, their trade is worth around 3 nons.

All trades are fair (well, trade 2 depends on your values) since all of them are worth at least 1 non. Trade 3 is worth the most. Trade 2 would probably be worth the least.
If you want to keep it safe, i'd go with trade 1 since they offer good/normal demand pets that are high in value. If you wanna go for most value, then trade 3 although it may be hard trading the fruits away. If you really like the UR Fox, then i'd go with trade 2 but demand for new URs are fluctuating because they're new (personally, i'd wait for it to settle).