The "is this a fair trade?" Thread - info front page!

[minccino]

Since I don't think it would be okay to quote all the replies I got and said I'll just say your names ^.^
To RainWingThing and Vixey thanks for the help :3

[|Lace|]

is this fair?

[Kandra]

Vixey,
thank you very much! ^_^

[ThunderCedar]

is this fair?

looks a bit unfair to them, going by dates just their 2013 common is about right for your pet. Though a common for a rare always feels a little off- even then, it feels like they added a bit too much^^ looks like a good trade for you

edit;; no problem!^

[Heavenly paws]

How fair is this?

[Fleetwood]

I have these two offers on my BMD, but I don't know if they're fair or not.
Offer one, plus they're willing to add a purple sleipnir and Offer two

[Zombilon]

How fair is this?

Very unfair to the top.
Scourge can go for an '09 rare himself, possibly more, and those 2016 commons on your end don't add up to anything.
Not to mention bunny demand is rather low.

[ThunderCedar]

How fair is this?

In terms of pure rarity, it's not bad--. Their cloudstar (i think that was the name?) warrior was available til 2010 and is worth a mid 2010 rare, with the scourge warrior they could arguably add up to between an early 2010 rare to a late 09 rare. So in that sense, you are overpaying a little.
Though both their pets tend to go for higher prices than this, that would be up to you and your partner. I could see them going for 2-3 09 rares together, reasonably.

I have these two offers on my BMD, but I don't know if they're fair or not.
Offer one, plus they're willing to add a purple sleipnir and Offer two

the 2nd one is very close to fair by list, the BMD's worth 5 mid advents and they have around this much, maybe an 09 rare off but the list isn't strict enough for use to argue on that.
I wouldn't take it though, it's a pretty known fact that the BMD can fetch overpay, and they are not offering any. none of their pets have any special demand to cover that gap.
the 1st one is overpay, 500 C$ is about a balloon dog, which is what i've seen a lot of people value the BMD at in the past.
But I don't recommend trading off the list, especially for raw C$, as it can be pretty hard to get back on it.

[Katskatskats]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SRPa5zRBhg

[grizol]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... pSy8nerffw
Is this fair? I know the cat is popular i think?