The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Wysterinka]

I definitely need help with this trade: trades/viewtrade.php?id=111423703&userid=191502&signature=owW45NrUfbAVhyuA3RMXOg . I'm not sure how much the items are worth.

The trick or treat item to the collar are all 1-2 old rares since these were 2009. Generally I haven't been trading any items from 09 as uncommon so I'd say they are overpaying.

[Wysterinka]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111431867&userid=1045569&signature=yd38ud17HDrz_QU-zLG0BQ
fair? ty for any help

Very unfair to item side. 11 of those are limited store set items. The whole set been going for 1MA+ for quite some time now.

[Wysterinka]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111441826&userid=589173&signature=tlNpvao4YbjjUU3PtEiPWw

Don’t know anything about items, is this fair ?

The items are generally newer and none of them are really demanded so I'd say the pets here are way better, since they have high demand.

[TrashCanCat]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111446205

Thoughts on this? I'm not too sure.

[answrs]

I'm pretty sure this is fair (or overpay (?)) but figured I'd grab an opinion since I'm unsure what the "old rares" thing means when it comes to store values. (I was told '10s?)

thank you for help!

[Mina Ashido]

Is this a fair trade? I'm really trying to trade off this apple
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111446390&userid=867326&signature=xO8io3x0jbc0JH6sBp4ZHw

[Mina Ashido]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111446205

Thoughts on this? I'm not too sure.

wrong link <3 try the one at the very bottom of the trade!

[Never & Rush]

i keep getting anxious about trying to trade my older pets for newer ones please tell me if this is unfair for them! i tried to kinda calculate out how much everything would cost in C$ if either side was for C$ and high-balled the lions since i know they have good demand, but i just want to make sure it's at least fair for them ^^;

[MrAnkle]

need help with these c$ pets and high value stuff!!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111444798&userid=986678&signature=hu6lhf5w1W4lmD_OvC6L8Q

[OreozHere]

i keep getting anxious about trying to trade my older pets for newer ones please tell me if this is unfair for them! i tried to kinda calculate out how much everything would cost in C$ if either side was for C$ and high-balled the lions since i know they have good demand, but i just want to make sure it's at least fair for them ^^;

if you use the 2:1 year for dates then they are underpaying!

need help with these c$ pets and high value stuff!!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111444798&userid=986678&signature=hu6lhf5w1W4lmD_OvC6L8Q

according to horrors list your side is technically worth 2 old rares and theirs is 4, but i am hesitant to agree since the bwolfs are already extremely rare! i would say your side is worth 4 old rares at least, so i believe it would be fair if you dont mind trading down!