The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[gravity]

Hiii can somebody help me with this trade: Here
Thanks in advance!

[jprspereira]

Hiii can somebody help me with this trade: Here
Thanks in advance!

Their side: I counted 4.6MA roughly of bulk VRs, maybe 5MA due to some being good demand.
Your side: 5.5MA (1 is TD so its 1.5MA, the others are 1MA each).

[Snippet-1213]

Is this trade fair? I’m not as experienced with trades over .5 ma worth and even then I’m a little confused sometimes ^^ any help is greatly appreciated!

You'd be overpaying. It's 1MA on their side for 1.9MA on yours.

Thanks for the advice! How many if any store pets should I remove to make it more balanced?

[jprspereira]

Is this trade fair? I’m not as experienced with trades over .5 ma worth and even then I’m a little confused sometimes ^^ any help is greatly appreciated!

You'd be overpaying. It's 1MA on their side for 1.9MA on yours.

Thanks for the advice! How many if any store pets should I remove to make it more balanced?

Your Mythological Dog is a fair swap already (1MA).

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114031986&userid=755258&signature=qGoCadyP3aHgvLpyWNFYUg

Admittedly I’m not that well-versed in trades so I wanted to get opinions from people who actually know what they’re talking about lol

This is extremely unfair to you. I wouldn't even suggest editing, just too messy of a trade xD

[Mazzikin]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114031986&userid=755258&signature=qGoCadyP3aHgvLpyWNFYUg

Admittedly I’m not that well-versed in trades so I wanted to get opinions from people who actually know what they’re talking about lol

This is way unfair to you, a lot of your pets are old and the oldest pet they’re offering is from 2016, I wouldn’t even try to edit I would just cancel, alot of the pets they’re offering you can be found for free in alot of adoption centres and isn’t worth the sheer amount of rares you’d be trading for them IMO. VERY unfair

[hextech]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114032129&userid=886939&signature=zJkm1hx5ujz4tQaovlBL5Q

is this fair? thank you in advance :]

It's 1MA of value on both sides, so it's fair. Depends on which side you prefer ^^ If you want their pets, it's a good option. If you would use them as trading fodder, your side is better to trade away.

thank you!! i actually just got another offer on the same pet, so i'm wondering if this one is fair as well and it's just a matter of choosing which pets i want more, or if i should choose one over the other?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114032209&userid=886939&signature=qNtjTjHnDhDJpoWUQTkg6A

thank you again!

[psychomoment]

hey yall, what do you think of this trade? haven't been on in a decade so im basically a newbie again lol

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114032451&userid=462394&signature=HsObGVtj5TgJMdxyLD1ylg

[MrAnkle]

is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=114028056&userid=986678&signature=Z8P2qOpNed5yTfG2dNtsew

i definitely would like the pets on their side, but i don't know if this is overpay! :,)

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114032237&userid=986678&signature=ZdkcGIRoOQTPmGu33aOGNQ
and this UR horse!

[lucidmaws]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114032408&userid=888783&signature=qz-f1cP8owguARY6U1224w

any help is greatly appreciated!

[jprspereira]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=114032129&userid=886939&signature=zJkm1hx5ujz4tQaovlBL5Q

is this fair? thank you in advance :]

It's 1MA of value on both sides, so it's fair. Depends on which side you prefer ^^ If you want their pets, it's a good option. If you would use them as trading fodder, your side is better to trade away.

thank you!! i actually just got another offer on the same pet, so i'm wondering if this one is fair as well and it's just a matter of choosing which pets i want more, or if i should choose one over the other?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=114032209&userid=886939&signature=qNtjTjHnDhDJpoWUQTkg6A

thank you again!

Now they're offering 1.1MA (= 11 2010/2011 rares) for your 1MA (= 10 2010/2011 rares) + a recent EUC. They're slightly overpaying, but I think what's important here is whether you'd want their pets or not. 1MA Dogs will always be easier to trade away than normal 2010/2011 rares.