New Thread please lock <3

[kivr & fireflii]

I have two trades that I need help with. c:
x
x

1. Unfair to Nick horse, but not by a lot
2. About fair, but get another opinion

[Evvor]

It's a bid for this guy -

So, I'm trying to rank this bid, how close to fair is it?

Also, if you were to compare the bid above to this one, which is the better bid?

Thanks so much! n_n

Also, would this be fair?

[Clowesia]

I have two trades that I need help with. c:
x
x

1. Unfair to Nick horse, but not by a lot
2. About fair, but get another opinion

Thank you Toki babyface. |D<3

[Space Cadet Marz]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... aj0dGT8_kQ Any thoughts on this.

[Bugmo33]

I have two trades that I need help with. c:
x
x

I think the top trade is unfair to you. But I'm not that sure. And I have no clue about the second trade.

[jellyballoo]

Is this fair?

[Bugmo33]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=10380958&userid=22959&signature=du5FhUD4o4hEaj0dGT8_kQ Any thoughts on this.

Personally, I believe it is unfair to the bottom.

[yumekari]

Thank you! How about

2009-05 Rare
for
2008-11 Uncommon
2008-12 Uncommon?

That looks pretty okay in my opinion. Maybe slightly unfair to the dog side, but you'll need another opinion on that ^^

Thanks! ^^ Any second opinions?

[Kaliyana]

Fair? Unfair?
If unfair to which side?

I have one slightly unfair to the SunJewel; second opinion please?

[Ashki]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=10380958&userid=22959&signature=du5FhUD4o4hEaj0dGT8_kQ Any thoughts on this.

Personally, I believe it is unfair to the bottom.

I agree, unfair to bottom in my opinion.