The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[.crossfire.]

would this trade be better than a swap for my grapes? (other trade was a spotted tibal as a swap)

i was told it would be about half a non if i value the bun at its "rarity placement" but i dont recall it being on the list? any ideas?

xxxx

their side is about 4.5 mid advents (im valuing the robot dog at 2-3 2009 rares here, maximum, just to give their sides maximum value)
by "rarity placement", they likely mean its placement on the new rarity GUIDE. whether you follow it or not is up to you, but its placement here is as a "mid advent" (its labelled as the "teal malk bunny")
your grapes are worth 5-6 mid advents (which is equal to 0.5 nons), so its slightly unfair to you. the spotted tribal is a fair straight swap, but the tribal doesnt have much better demand.
the bunny on the new rarity guide, however, might not be recognized for its listed value by some people who stick to the older guide.

overall, would this trade be better than the spotted tribal?

[caster.]

Is this fair? And what are those items valued at?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92062526&userid=796216&signature=DcGlqMXvSg8aKwW0qAz-Iw

Orange soda - 2011 CS Bday
White July Sticker - 2012 CS Bday
Green Scarf - 2012 Christmas


This one too
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92064275&userid=796216&signature=r6VYN0hhuepvgS2GvS3yBA


And this one 🙃
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92064448&userid=796216&signature=Fnwjq4r6KlWrsA3jD1uhyQ

[Alina]

is this trade fair demand wise for my black advent?

[The Score]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92038904&userid=609083&signature=8-7c9c-0ziWBVTpWYIoRjA

please help!!

they are overpaying, the rainbow mane is worth 1350 C$ so it really comes down to if you want C$ for the pet or not. get another opinion

Another opinion please!!!

[Andromeda123]

This?

also this?


Should I accept any of these? Take demand into consideration please

[☽isa☾]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92038081&userid=952047&signature=7E7sNxTChczP4meb5UhhrQ

Is this fair? I’m not too familiar with store pet worths...

Thanks!

theyre overpaying (2020 store pet = late 2010 rare)

[gunthyr]

would this trade be better than a swap for my grapes? (other trade was a spotted tibal as a swap)

i was told it would be about half a non if i value the bun at its "rarity placement" but i dont recall it being on the list? any ideas?

xxxx

their side is about 4.5 mid advents (im valuing the robot dog at 2-3 2009 rares here, maximum, just to give their sides maximum value)
by "rarity placement", they likely mean its placement on the new rarity GUIDE. whether you follow it or not is up to you, but its placement here is as a "mid advent" (its labelled as the "teal malk bunny")
your grapes are worth 5-6 mid advents (which is equal to 0.5 nons), so its slightly unfair to you. the spotted tribal is a fair straight swap, but the tribal doesnt have much better demand.
the bunny on the new rarity guide, however, might not be recognized for its listed value by some people who stick to the older guide.

overall, would this trade be better than the spotted tribal?

personally, i'd say its overall not a better swap, solely because i havent seen the bunny fetch nearly as much as its listed value often or recently.

[FrostbitenRoses]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92063795&userid=661506&signature=kYSTqNMFNDPE6GSni4FcIg

[Lord Ghirahim]

Hi! I'm looking for advice on this trade? (: Thanks in advance!

[☽isa☾]

Is this fair? And what are those items valued at?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92062526&userid=796216&signature=DcGlqMXvSg8aKwW0qAz-Iw

Orange soda - 2011 CS Bday
White July Sticker - 2012 CS Bday
Green Scarf - 2012 Christmas


This one too
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92064275&userid=796216&signature=r6VYN0hhuepvgS2GvS3yBA


And this one 🙃
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92064448&userid=796216&signature=Fnwjq4r6KlWrsA3jD1uhyQ

I'm sorry I don't know the worth of the items, but for all three trades the other side is overpaying. For the last trade they're only slightly overpaying though, so it's your preference (you might like quantity more, for example). The first trade, even without the items, they are WAY overpaying !