The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[iyori]

I have absolutely no idea. Thanks in advance!

[master of spaz]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ScQJaU5UPw
No clue for item value. Any help?

[ruel]

I have absolutely no idea. Thanks in advance!

Those items are pretty recent while they are offering some older pets and items, I would take it

[ShadowStride]

Okay, I need some good advice on quantity trades CX
(This includes recent event pets)
So I've been offered 17 of these BW, and 56 of these dragons.
Would an advent pet be closer to the worth of these? Or multiple advent pets?
(I know the rarities aren't out yet, but I'm guessing that the dragons are going to be rare because they are a late release token pet and the BW is going to be uncommon-common because it was a later release freebie)
If not, what could this quantity of pets go for?

If anyone could help me with this as soon as possible, it would be greatly appreciated!
EDIT- If anyone does happen to answer, could you PM me what you think? It's hard for me to follow up on this thread sometimes!
Thank you so very much!

[Smaug The Dragon]

Fair for both sides? Should I accept this?
What about this one to? Is it fair rarity AND DEMAND wise? I don't like rats, so I don't know.
Would you accept these trades?
And this too...
And this? Is it fair for my partner and I? Does anything need to be added? ^^

[-Nightmare]

How is this bid?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LSsFoHeI_w
I know the demand for jokers is pretty high but what does it usually go for?
would a Joker + Red Rose Dog + Target Dog = coontail?
OR Marionette Dog + Joker = coontail?

Thanks in advance!

[Sweetfrog]

Demand wise is this fair without the cat?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... k9ehG8z28A

May I get one more opinion?

[Antipathy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68328187&userid=661028&signature=aSpZ8ijMw7JjScQJaU5UPw
No clue for item value. Any help?

All the items they are asking for are from Summer Event-Christmas 2013. Valuing each at an uncommon from the same year, the pet side is overpaying.

[Dysautonomia]

I was at work yesterday so I'm a bit behind and I have a few trades left I'm unsure of.
Any help would be super appreciated.

1. Rat List. I believe this might be fair but I'm not sure with demand factored in?

2. this trade is super tempting to me - however, I'm not sure if it's fair value wise?

[neuroticism]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hgcSC_ht8w
Is this a good bid? What should I rate it? Thank you so much!