The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[juyeo]

Hi! I would like some personal opinions on this trade. Would you take it? The bunny is a tier 1 advent c:

-snip-

Oooh okay, personally no I wouldn't take it. This is only because once you're off the list it's extremely hard to get back on it

Okay, thank you! Can I please have a second opinion? c:

[hummxs]

would you guys take this? the ur bwolf has high list value but i know it's hard to get fair trades for it...not sure what to do

I'm the other side, would like an opinion for gloaming as well. Thanks!

This is fair in my opinion

Please do not post opinions unless you have something to help them rarity-wise. This counts as unwanted advice and/or spam.

I personally believe this is fair since the UR B-Wolf is worth a Purple Toxic + 3 nons, and the CEG is worth a Purple Toxic and a Balloon Dog, which is worth around 3 Blue Roses. I personally think it's up to demand, though, since I've seen the CEG go for more than a UR B-Wolf lately.

[hashtag]

would you guys take this? the ur bwolf has high list value but i know it's hard to get fair trades for it...not sure what to do

I'm the other side, would like an opinion for gloaming as well. Thanks!

This is unfair to the person with the CEG. The ur bwolf usually goes for less than a non, and the CEG along can fetch higher than a non, plus the vixen has high demand, too.

[juyeo]

Hi! I would like some personal opinions on this trade. Would you take it? The bunny is a tier 1 advent c:

-snip-

Oooh okay, personally no I wouldn't take it. This is only because once you're off the list it's extremely hard to get back on it

Okay, thank you! Can I please have a second opinion? c:

[SteampunkAngel]

Hi! I would like some personal opinions on this trade. Would you take it? The bunny is a tier 1 advent c:

-snip-

Oooh okay, personally no I wouldn't take it. This is only because once you're off the list it's extremely hard to get back on it

Okay, thank you! Can I please have a second opinion? c:

It depends because through offsite trades it can be a lot easier to get hold of list pets but people usually expect overpay to trade off the list themselves which can be a little unfair. But the llamas also have pretty good demand and would depend if you wanted to try to get a better list pet for the bunny (I try to plan my trading paths for my lists).

[beemo]

would you guys take this? the ur bwolf has high list value but i know it's hard to get fair trades for it...not sure what to do

I'm the other side, would like an educated opinion for gloaming as well. Thanks!

[SteampunkAngel]

would you guys take this? the ur bwolf has high list value but i know it's hard to get fair trades for it...not sure what to do

I'm the other side, would like an educated opinion for gloaming as well. Thanks!

Hmm the B-Wolf doesn't tend to have the greatest demand but I couldn't tell you what it goes for, I just know it's harder to trade off than the CEG and Vixen. The Vixen is popular but I wouldn't value it above it's tier. The CEG of course can go anywhere from tier value and up right now (though again I don't agree it's worth a non like some people). So to me it's insane overpay, I just don't like the butterfly wolf x

[lines]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... H5Vqdf7I0Q


i was wondering if this is a fair trade?? if not, for who and why??

[beemo]

would you guys take this? the ur bwolf has high list value but i know it's hard to get fair trades for it...not sure what to do

I'm the other side, would like an educated opinion for gloaming as well. Thanks!

Hmm the B-Wolf doesn't tend to have the greatest demand but I couldn't tell you what it goes for, I just know it's harder to trade off than the CEG and Vixen. The Vixen is popular but I wouldn't value it above it's tier. The CEG of course can go anywhere from tier value and up right now (though again I don't agree it's worth a non like some people). So to me it's insane overpay, I just don't like the butterfly wolf x

Thanks, I don't mind if the Vixen gets removed, I'd do a straight swap. I personally think the BW can go for closer to 2 Nons than 1, but I just needed some other's advice.

[juyeo]

would you guys take this? the ur bwolf has high list value but i know it's hard to get fair trades for it...not sure what to do

I'm the other side, would like an educated opinion for gloaming as well. Thanks!

Hmm the B-Wolf doesn't tend to have the greatest demand but I couldn't tell you what it goes for, I just know it's harder to trade off than the CEG and Vixen. The Vixen is popular but I wouldn't value it above it's tier. The CEG of course can go anywhere from tier value and up right now (though again I don't agree it's worth a non like some people). So to me it's insane overpay, I just don't like the butterfly wolf x

Alrighty! Thank you both!