The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Defying Gravity]

--
Apple for red toxic? :3

Unfair to red toxic

[NocturnalPanda]

what about : blue and green firework dogs ('09) and the later growing spider from this month for 7 zodiacs and this rat:

anyone??

It would help a lot if you also posted what you are hoping to trade these for - what the other side of the offer is.

If you want to know the value of those pets, head over to What Is This Pet Worth? thread.

ummm... i did.

they want:
the blue and green firework dogs and the later growing spider from this month

they will give me:
7 zodiacs and the rat.

[Ventru]

Is this fair? I really like the pets, especially the Rare dog...

Unfair to you ^^
--
Apple for red toxic? :3

unfair to toxic

[Diabolic]

what about : blue and green firework dogs ('09) and the later growing spider from this month for 7 zodiacs and this rat:

It would help a lot if you also posted what you are hoping to trade these for - what the other side of the offer is.

If you want to know the value of those pets, head over to What Is This Pet Worth? thread.

ummm... i did.

they want:
the blue and green firework dogs and the later growing spider from this month

they will give me:
7 zodiacs and the rat.

It never once in your original post says 'for' :] Thus it seems like all those pets are in one bunch on one side.

As for the trade then... Well, that rat isn't worth very much. But they are offering you 7 dogs along with it... Hm. I'd say quite fair, or then a little unfair to you. But I'm not very good with rats.

[Seasonal]

Ack, I was hoping that would be fair. I want to get rid of the white dragon as soon as possible because I have a feeling it will become Rare if more hatch. >.>;

I would say unfair to the Red Toxic. The Apple's popularity and value has decreased. I could be wrong, though.
I'm winning an auction for an apple with the dragon, and I'm tired with someone who offered 3 VR bunnies. Those bids are probably unfair to the apple, though. Ask someone else, because I'm useless. x3

[riley.∞]

Okays, I've had an offer on my White July... I have no idea what do to do!

Well I can offer a winged wood dog, one of the rare PPS pups from july 09 a blue spotted october, a up to 4 rare rats from the 08 advent calendar, this rare dog:
and a rare happy birthday shadow cat. plus a halo if you want it.
I just had another trade for one cancelled tonight. Thanks so much for letting me offer on yours. (I can add my floppy eared pink september if you want it. )

Would you like my offer more if I added my rose pps to it? And the 2 holly dogs and nick birthday dog from 2008? I could give you this rat from your wishlist.

And this:



Is this better? (keep in mind this is in addition to what I previously offered.)
~Ani

This is all one offer.

Hello~? I'd like some quick feedback, don't want to keep the person waiting...

[Ventru]

What could I get if I auctioned off my July PPS?

hmm.. it's in the top 5 rarest pets, I believe, I think you can get at least 2/3 VR's for it.

[Diabolic]

What could I get if I auctioned off my July PPS?

I do believe that question belongs in the What's This Pet Worth? thread :]

[Seasonal]

Fair? Unfair? What could they add if it is unfair?

[NocturnalPanda]

It would help a lot if you also posted what you are hoping to trade these for - what the other side of the offer is.

If you want to know the value of those pets, head over to What Is This Pet Worth? thread.

ummm... i did.

they want:
the blue and green firework dogs and the later growing spider from this month

they will give me:
7 zodiacs and the rat.

It never once in your original post says 'for' :] Thus it seems like all those pets are in one bunch on one side.

As for the trade then... Well, that rat isn't worth very much. But they are offering you 7 dogs along with it... Hm. I'd say quite fair, or then a little unfair to you. But I'm not very good with rats.

i did actually, if you check the first time i posted that message (pg 5 or something and then on pg 20 +23 i think) it says 'for' and i didnt edit it in those posts, i just underlined it to show that i did actually put both sides but anyway thank you for your input. How do you think it could be made more fair? remove the spider from the offer?