The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[poorturtle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92219905&userid=566020&signature=Q8DS60A3PmR03mNhYc1LeA
(link should be fixed now)

oh god I dont have a clue how much these items are worth.. please help me lol

[Octopia]

Is the first still best?
yikes

Bid 1
2 wl rare (1 -2009, 1 -1010) 2 wl vr storepets (2012)
-
Bid 2
10 wl R (6 -2010, 1 -2013, 3 -2015), 7 wl UC (2013)+ 13 wl items)
-
Bid 3
2 wl rare (2009), 1 wl vr (2009) c$180
-
Bid 4
8 wl rare, 1 wl vr (all 2010)
-
Bid 5
1 wl '11 rare, 16 wl rares (1 -2011, 2 -2010)
-

I need an answer today please!

[Mythz]

x

xx

Thank you for help!



1. Going with 1 09 VR = 2 09 R and the 3 month rule, this trade is unfair to you!
2. 2 11 rares = 1 2010 rares, 2 2010 rares = 1 09 rare. This trade is also unfair to you c:
(Not including any demand any pets may have)



any help with this? thank you !


The Panda PPS on their side is from 09, worth the 3 month rule. That + The extra rare is overpay on their side c:
(Not including any demand any pets may have)



https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92219905
oh god I dont have a clue how much these items are worth.. please help me lol


Wrong link! Make sure to go to the bottom of the trade and copy the link there <3

[×Seven of Nine×]

they're looking for offers so idk if they'll accept anything anyway but I'm curious is this fair for the August pps lion considering demand?

link

[SussyMangos]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92190599&userid=948896&signature=bhgNXHBtdkJPAGtGPbfusg
trades/viewtrade.php?id=92213562&userid=948896&signature=lxU1Tx6-1rk-uFy5C1rELw
How are these?

[she wolf warrior]

is this fair? i’m terrible with item rarities ^^;
thank you!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92220414&userid=635367&signature=R4KbVWkRcLAFI3u_XTkfaQ

[rileypillow]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92220448&userid=999540&signature=BlGhofG1JgO4aEWqzzmWqA

[tonio]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=92220448&userid=999540&signature=BlGhofG1JgO4aEWqzzmWqA

Wouldn't recommend, yours is from may 2009 so they're underpaying

[rileypillow]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92220448&userid=999540&signature=BlGhofG1JgO4aEWqzzmWqA

Thank you!

What can I add to make it fair? Would two old uncommons be enough, or does it need another rare added?

[tonio]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=92220448&userid=999540&signature=BlGhofG1JgO4aEWqzzmWqA

Thank you!

What can I add to make it fair? Would two old uncommons be enough, or does it need another rare added?

Something like the VR rabbit and a 2009 rare would be fair for your dog, or another 2010 VR/2 2010 rares if they have it