The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[flora]

aaaa I value the sleipnir as a low september list, but is this worth it? ;n; I have no idea what the rose pps goes go normally

also reposting this, if me valuing the sleipnir as a low september is ridiculously high, please do correct me. ;n;

[flora]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=77055415&userid=926996&signature=dakurOFOjF5NoPKj68Xd1w

The butterfly wolf is from 2010 originally

I would say it's fair. The tigers are storepets, therefore are worth early - mid '10 rares. Not sure which month the b.wolf is from in 2010 though. ^^

[Topiratti]

]are any of these fair?

for the august PPS lion i value you it at a mid to high advent, to a low september

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77069136&userid=10993&signature=Tn53Ko6GilGb38PMUMZb8A

not what the peach or zebra go for

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77067388&userid=10993&signature=hA72pnguz4GVeqqVwgXutg

not sure about this one

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77019067&userid=10993&signature=Y_M2sgeRNeeTAe9mtYR11Q

sldo got this, it seems unfair to me - note i vlure the beg and ur malk at a non each, does this total almost 3 nons worth? does it cover any of the pets?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77070200&userid=10993&signature=XfhIJ-V6m7NJnJudms2goQ

please do not reply if you are unsure or do not know the list please

thanks for time an help.

[Targaryen]

this? and this?
please help. i’ve been asking for many pages now (:
-alura

For the second one, I believe it is unfair to the pet side as the eggs are normally only worth an uncommon from the same year. Only eggs 1-2 (or 1-4?) are worth greatly. here's the eggie guild! I cannot help much with your first trade however though, I'm sorry!

thank you. can i get another opinion? and some help on the first trade please?

Really depends how you value the sunback and how you value quantity, some people want between 2-5 nons for it.
You can fairly easily get a non for each CEG/BEG, the basilik set is fairly high demand and will obviously continue to do so as a store pet and the quantity is fairly nice and hard to come by. However, if you value the sunback as 3+ nons, id think you could maybe push for a bit more for it. I don't think the quantity is enough to justify the gap between 2 and 3 nons.

[AmberRise]

PLEASE HELP!
Is this a fair trade??
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77073523&userid=869053&signature=0_7tV2QbRLMd4RitFfW0Fg

[Likaon]

Hi! Is it fair? Would you personally take this?

[Corey Taylor]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=77075876&userid=781126&signature=PuuXXc03KOitVvuAQFolGg

Is this fair at all?

[etherealsig]

I'm rly not sure about this trade since I have no clue what the lion pps is actually worth - is this fair at all? :0 thanks!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77063102&userid=247373&signature=TTnqysPXhlZO_Tu7SDQ4RA

[KkSpecial]

this? and this?
please help. i’ve been asking for many pages now (:
-alura

For the second one, I believe it is unfair to the pet side as the eggs are normally only worth an uncommon from the same year. Only eggs 1-2 (or 1-4?) are worth greatly. here's the eggie guild! I cannot help much with your first trade however though, I'm sorry!

Second Opinion on Trade 2
I agree with Astria - this was unfair to the pet side.

Animal Egg 34 & 35 = 1 2013 Uncommon each
Animal Egg 46 = 1 2014 Uncommon

1 2013 Rare = 4 2013 Uncommons
1 2017 Rare = 1 2015 Uncommon

Animal Eggs 1-2 are worth a Main List pet each and Animal Eggs 3-4 are worth a September List pet each.
All of the other Animal Eggs - if they are not found on the slightly out of date Rare Item Guide then they are typically worth 1 Common/Uncommon from the year of release.

[the]

PLEASE HELP!
Is this a fair trade??
trades/viewtrade.php?id=77073523&userid=869053&signature=0_7tV2QbRLMd4RitFfW0Fg

Unfair to you. Their dog is worth a mid-late rare '09 due to extended release and a '15 store pet is worth a late rare '09, so the store dog on your side isn't needed.

Hi! Is it fair? Would you personally take this?

2 rares '10 = rare '09
Their dog is oryginally from January 2009 and would have been fair for your cats. All other pets on their side are overpay.