The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Simon]

April 2009 Very rare
+
??
=

November 2008 Very rare

The green pastel dog has not been VR for long, whereas the growing strawberry has been VR for a long time. I would say either fair or add just like a teeeeeeeeny bit to the strawberry. Seriously, no more than like a 2012 rare or something.

Thank you very much for your help <3 ^^
Second opinion anyone?

I'd have to disgree.
Even if it has been only for a short time,it still has it's worth.
So I'd say add a 09 rare or so.

I have to agree with ocean here

Values arn't based on the length of rarity it has had.

An 09 rare would work here.

[tawnypelt3]

I have to agree with ocean here

Values arn't based on the length of rarity it has had.

An 09 rare would work here.

It's fine if you wanna disagree with me, but..... "Values aren't based on the length of rarity it has had."

Yes, they kinda are. >-> Take 2 2010 rares. Same species, same, demand, even the same month. One has been rare for several years. One has been rare for several months. Which is more valuable? Obviously the first one. How long something has been common, uncommon, rare, etc. contributes to its relative worth the same as its actual rarity, or its species, demand, etc.

I think adding another 2009 rare would be too much, because that would make the strawberry's side equivalent to a bottom/lower tier Advent List pet. Remember, the bottom tier is worth 3 early 2009 rares.

[Nightsky.]

Is this fair? If not, what needs to be changed? Thanks in advance! c:

Quite unfair to them. The Dark Leopard is high on the September list and the Pink Balloon is on the Mains list. You may need to offer quite a few more in this trade.

So if they took out the dark leopard, what would they have to add to make up the difference between the Balloon and ice cat? Thank you for the answer and your time. :3

Sorry for the late reply :3

You may need to add a few more very rares. We're talking maybe 4 to 5 more depending on the years. The balloon dogs have a high demand and won't be traded very easily. Good luck though!

[poppins]

Is the cream advent fair to 160 BWs? It includes 3 rares 66 commons, 60 uncommons, and 37 vcs or something like that. Thanks!

[SluLooLoo]

Is this fair? Any help would be great, thanks!

[Isa Novak]

Which is more fair;;

This one or this one?

[Ayallah]

is a good offer to trade my non-swirl against a UR pot? I know that the pot is somewhere between the non-tag and the dog-tag but do they have good demand? Thanks for help!

[Sonmi-451]

Is this fair? Any help would be great, thanks!

Unfair to the Sorbet.

[Ayallah]

is a good offer to trade my non-swirl against a UR pot? I know that the pot is somewhere between the non-tag and the dog-tag but do they have good demand? Thanks for help!

[Fruity Girl]

Which is more fair;;

This one or this one?

They're both unfair to the other person. Neither of them are fair.
If your question is which one is overpaying more, I'd say the 1st one. c;