The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[updog]

Is this trade fair for my pps roadkill?

bumping as partner

[Quackers <3]

I'm not too familiar with the Corgis value. Does this trade look fair?

[JayJay]

Is this trade fair for my pps roadkill?

bumping as partner

Slightly unfair to the dog and C$ side from what I can tell. Roadkill average C$ worth is 250 according to this forum, so the dog is extra. Please feel free to get a second opinion.

what is the average conversion of uncommon to rare? thank you

sam

So a lot of players have different conversions on valuing their pets rarities. Also dates can (and usually do) play a key role in how they value that uncommon/rare. A norm is usually 2:1 (I personally do this) but I have seen a lot of players have more of a 3:1 while others will only trade rares for rares. Best advice is to communicate with your trading partner and find out what they preference and also figure out what works out best for you. Every player values their pets differently. Please feel free to get a second opinion.

[Lee-Sins]

Is this trade fair for my pps roadkill?

Slightly unfair to the dog and C$ side from what I can tell. Roadkill average C$ worth is 250 according to this forum, so the dog is extra. Please feel free to get a second opinion.

I'm pretty sure this would be unfair to the Roadkill PPS.
It's listed as a low september worth 1.5-2 MA. The C$ covers 1MA at the lowest value. The dog doesn't cover the remaining.

1MA is anywhere between 250-350. More commonly at the 300C$ mark.

[Aidoneus]

Is this trade fair? Thanks in advance for any help!

[JayJay]

Is this trade fair for my pps roadkill?

Slightly unfair to the dog and C$ side from what I can tell. Roadkill average C$ worth is 250 according to this forum, so the dog is extra. Please feel free to get a second opinion.

I'm pretty sure this would be unfair to the Roadkill PPS.
It's listed as a low september worth 1.5-2 MA. The C$ covers 1MA at the lowest value. The dog doesn't cover the remaining.

1MA is anywhere between 250-350. More commonly at the 300C$ mark.

I respect your opinion and input. I have not personally seen the roadkill pps go higher than 1.5MA, but here are some successful C$ trades for the PPS roadkill pony (which is what I have been going on). Everyone does value their pets differently, so you could very well be correct, this is just the information that I have seen in my trades and research. I wish you all the best of luck in trading.

[Nari UwU]

C$ for items

I'm bad at item values, any advice?

[luckydraw]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97024487&userid=816125&signature=7HR5WgBnacfIthTtLTpLQw

Any help on whether this is fair would be appreciated.

[Ruruskadoo]

I know trades with items are harder to evaluate but that's exactly why I need help please T^T

trades/viewtrade.php?id=96992021&userid=119355&signature=WIZfLfxOTq2qKd3mGjyZBA


trades/viewtrade.php?id=96998442&userid=119355&signature=coOq_YZOw09EpgBKM2NETA


trades/viewtrade.php?id=97008112&userid=119355&signature=SD1BkiA1XSCNq1-NF5QDpQ

[Assumed Gender]

Demand wise is this fair? I already know general fairness
trade