The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[J.cole]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58682487&userid=825758&signature=a85zZ1Vnbft-BOkkfwrAgw
is this fair rarity and demand wise?
this one too
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58684426&userid=825758&signature=B-U3RXPX-Hyf7yfW4aIW_w
are these trades fair?

the first trade is very unfair to you, their side barely adds up to a non-balloon, so they'd need to add at least a UR Flower + around a blue rose to make it fair.

& I added up the second trade, the pets & items adding up to around a striped pink september/red rose dog tier, and the C$ to blue rose dog/grey dragon tier. And since the blue balloon is worth 3 blue roses, and their side adds up to (roughly) one blue rose + one red rose, it'd be unfair to you. But trade down trades tend to be like that anyway. So if I'm correct, it's technically unfair to you but a second opinion would be nice.

okay thank you

[Pudd;]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3n1xyLmo7A

Is this fair? What should they add?

[sushi.jocelyn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... l2ABTloNLw
Fair?

[pew]

hello, how is this bulk trade for my beg?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Vwz6HaTIpg
to make it easier, there are 52 '08-'10 rare dogs, (predominantly '09), 6 '08-'09 non list very rares (predominantly '09), a red fronted holly advent, gear back tribal, green grinner, red x pps and rose pps.
thank you!

the rare's list pets alone are worth a little more than a blue toxic if I added them correctly, and the 50+ rares and very rares could roughly equal 10 or 11 mid advents, give or take. Which is worth a red X PPS or low tier main list. So it would equal pretty much exactly or slightly less or over a CEG, based on the list placement. Demand wise the CEG does well, but trading down tends to result in overpay. So yes it's about fair, but a second opinion would be helpful here.

[Sapphiren]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58671518&userid=625725&signature=TiqIxNOB6Fhzl2ABTloNLw
Fair?

it looks fair. but i think you should get a second opinion

[Jack Pattillo]

. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... CGogAzWXyg

Would this be fair? Ignore the uncommon on their side. Thank you for any advice!

This is fair, if anything the UR butterfly wolf may be overpaying slightly, and from experience and what I've seen the demand for all those pets are pretty neutral

Thank you! Can I get a second opinion?

[Saibotsalis]

I've got two trades that I'm not even sure what to do with. Any help would be greatly appreciated!

Trade One
(2 pets in exchange for 24 items)

Trade Two
(40 pets in exchange for 71 items)

[corgiqueen]

is this trade fair? thanks!

[Destiel<3]

This is urgent! How is the trade, rarity and demand wise?

[pew]

This is urgent! How is the trade, rarity and demand wise?

rarity wise unfair to them. And sorbets have decent demand, but the BMD can honestly go for a low main list - maybe even balloon dog or higher, with a lucky trade. And the andriod and lolita have nice demand and can go well over their list placement. It's still unfair to them, and if you're looking to trade up onto the main list and higher I'd say it's a good offer.