New thread! please go there!

[Bleating Ram]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... m--nccIrkQ

May I have a second opinion please? c:

[Young and Beautiful]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=46934617&userid=270610&signature=RqRYcJE57eZtWBK0sb1lRg
Fair?

Unfair to them.

[[Shadow]]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... m--nccIrkQ

May I have a second opinion please? c:

Add an '09 rare onto your side. The clyde will soon be on the (most likely) 2nd tier of the advent list.

[FooeyJam]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=46933698&userid=298478&signature=XhIUwgOpyJqvHbl_8yFIdg

fair or no

[Bleating Ram]

Thanks!

[Manjikai]

Help? Can I get 2 opinions on this thanks!

[Bastet4]

Need some help!
Send this trade since we both had some doubles of wishlist items. I never ask for items people dont have doubles of. Didnt think they were that "wanted" of items--just some random ones.
Was I fair or not? And can you tell me why? Trying to learn more about items.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RYpEqXSSzg


BECAUSE I got this reply--
"No----- because that wouldn't be fair to me in any way,shape,or form. You can edit your side though from those items."
and this trade
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6IjdXOEd5w

I kinda thought my pocky, old angel wings, alice in wonderland set were worth a LOT more?
Am I wrong?
Should I just add some grass, a balloon and sand?
Not sure what is fair at all.
I was looking for only items, not pets.
What are their items worth? Thanks, and if there is an item thread, please link me!

Not super familiar with items but I know enough to help, I think.

Trade 1 - About fair. Maybe a bit unfair to them.

Trade 2 - The rough breakdown

Pocky - '08 Rare/VR
The plushies - Mid '09 rares each
Alice in Wonderland Set - Still available in stores. Worth maybe a 2012/2013 rare?
EDIT Chicken Smoothies - late '09/early '10 rare each from what I know but can easily get more.

So trade 2 on those items alone is super unfair to you.

Thanks for the breakdown!!!! Anyone else have anymore info for me to soak up?

[Cousincat]

Help? Can I get 2 opinions on this thanks!

I believe it it either fair or a little overpay on their side.
Considering a new store pet is 20 c$ and is worth a '10 rare, 24 c$ would be fair for. Late '09 The guinea pig just adds to it ^-^

[Manjikai]

Help? Can I get 2 opinions on this thanks!

I believe it it either fair or a little overpay on their side.
Considering a new store pet is 20 c$ and is worth a '10 rare, 24 c$ would be fair for. Late '09 The guinea pig just adds to it ^-^

Ok thank you! Second opninion please?

[kayyye]

Red Toxic = Green toxic + BA + Shima LT + Raven

Please tell me which of the three choices makes the trade most fair for the red toxic ^-^
Thank you!