The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[bfdi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=79505058&userid=947749&signature=D1xpoz_whfj51oohZ0e5-g
fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79505640&userid=947749&signature=fRFYLmJrT5B-6JjrivXGQA
and I would like to know whether this trade is fair?

[Alina]

How fair is this? They say their both our sides is worth 19.5 in 2010 value? Thanks c:

I also count about 19,5 2010 rares on both sides but on your side are only malk pets which tend to go for some slight overpay ^^
I would personally ask them to add or to replace some pets but rarity wise it is fair.

Feel free to get a second opinion!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79505058&userid=947749&signature=D1xpoz_whfj51oohZ0e5-g
fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79505640&userid=947749&signature=fRFYLmJrT5B-6JjrivXGQA
and I would like to know whether this trade is fair?

First trade: unfair to you, your pet is from 2009 and their side doesn’t add up to a 2009 very rare. (1 2009 vr = 2 2009 rares)
(Their dog is also from 2009 but the other pets on their side don’t add up to another 2009 rare so it’s unfair to you)

The second trade is unfair to them because the rat alone (2009 rerelease) would be fair rarity wise for the dog. The extra pets aren’t needed

Feel free to get another opinion^^

[Xeroxoe]

Hows this? xxxx
And this?
xxxx
xxx

[hellish]

hello!! do i have any chance of finding someone willing to trade my non-tag+ur aussie for their raven?
would it be a bad trade? i’m not sure what it goes for right now ;;

[Shirlyn]

I'm not good at trading that items - so is this trade fair to my 8 pets?

And that trade for my C$ Store Fennec?

And that one ?! I'm massive bad at trading items xD

Thanks for any opinions !

[hellish]

I'm not good at trading that items - so is this trade fair to my 8 pets?

And that trade for my C$ Store Fennec?

Thanks for any opinions !

just wanted to let you know that your second trade isn’t showing

[Alina]

hello!! do i have any chance of finding someone willing to trade my non-tag+ur aussie for their raven?
would it be a bad trade? i’m not sure what it goes for right now ;;

The non Tag alone would be overpay for the Raven.
Demand wise it also fetches about one non, so adding the ur Aussie on top would be extremely unfair to you

[Shirlyn]

I'm not good at trading that items - so is this trade fair to my 8 pets?

And that trade for my C$ Store Fennec?

Thanks for any opinions !

just wanted to let you know that your second trade isn’t showing

Hahaha thank you! I changed it

[hellish]

hello!! do i have any chance of finding someone willing to trade my non-tag+ur aussie for their raven?
would it be a bad trade? i’m not sure what it goes for right now ;;

The non Tag alone would be overpay for the Raven.
Demand wise it also fetches about one non, so adding the ur Aussie on top would be extremely unfair to you

okay, thank you for your answer! :>

[Zetirian]

Hows this? xxxx
And this?
xxxx
xxx

trades/viewtrade.php?id=79472276&userid=825141&signature=YlcKi1bPN1QLa2CjHDX47Q

Regarding this trade. I personally value all OMGSR's which just changed over on the same level as they are worth pretty much the same. This will come into play later.

Obviously using the Rare's list in it's current form will state that it is unfair to you. I personally do not believe this is the case considering that their place on the list has been overlooked for so long.

The idea of the list was to move all OMGSR's up above the "Big Gap" and anything below OMGSR it down. If this was the case, then if considering the lowest option for the OMGSR's potential placement was to be a UR Aussie Tier, then straight up the two rats together would be severely unfair to them in this trade. By strides and then some. You're looking at unfairness that varies from what a September list worth would be all the way to another OMGSR. It is up to you to put that decision together to figure this out, especially on how you value your pets vs theirs. I can tell you for sure that the Palmono horse is overpay extra.

This is purely rarity wise.

Honestly, I would trade low OMGSR for low OMGSR. What I mean by Low OMGSR, I mean a OMGSR which changed to VR and back ones or more during it's life. (Rainbow Mane for example) Because we know that these rats are over a theshold, the Nontag is only so far over that same threshold too. It cannot be said that it is so rare it is vastly over this gap in contrast to the two of the rats together.

But, as I said, their side is really unfair to them. The rats are worth so much more, and have been known to be worth so much more; this information was not accessible though, so many people didn't know and when the change happened, so many people were surprised. Except some older users.

I hope you use this knowledge to your benefit.