The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[.dylan.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76121764&userid=673904&signature=2s_3iN-mBbb0ItJXSSfdLg edited their trade, would it be fair now?

[This Is Halloween]

this for my ur rat? Idk the VR dogs worth ^^

they are also adding 692 other pets consisting of a few rares and mainly uncommon-very commons.
(I understand the 692 pets would be difficult to calculate for the rat but I'd like to just know the worth of the trade linked above )

edit; I'm taking underpay for the rat since of it's low demand. So about a sorber worth I'd like.

[nobxdy]

How fair was this? Either way I'm happy with the trade but I've always gone by 2 rares equals 1 from the previous year, is that true? Or is there a different rule? Thank you to anyone who helps! <3

It was unfair to them.
A 2009 rare is worth about 32 '14 rares, so those 2014 rares all the way to the first 2015 rare Bat would have been fair.
I figured this was the easiest way to calculate it. The rest is overpay. ^^

[mintfrogs]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76121830&userid=635867&signature=QhODjFNeW_N3XHcOBIPkcQ\

?

[.dylan.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76121830&userid=635867&signature=QhODjFNeW_N3XHcOBIPkcQ\

?

they are definitely overpaying, i'd take it

[nobxdy]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76121830&userid=635867&signature=QhODjFNeW_N3XHcOBIPkcQ

?

It's unfair to them. Even if your pets turned rare, it wouldn't be worth their side. (:

[stormsurge0]

How fair was this? Either way I'm happy with the trade but I've always gone by 2 rares equals 1 from the previous year, is that true? Or is there a different rule? Thank you to anyone who helps! <3

I won't do the exact math but I can tell you that as far as I got through like half of it but the old ones, it was a 2010 rare + a 2011 rare and you would only need another 2011 rare (of pets of earlier dates added up) to be 2 2010 which = a 2009 rare so either it was fair, super close to being fair, or a little bit of overpay on their side but more around the fair part

edit: just did the math and their giving you a pretty high overpay X3

[Konata.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76123502&userid=755077&signature=uIOoYN2MypXUbk-SM5gH1Q

what do you guys think?

[gahlaxied ♡]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=76123502&userid=755077&signature=uIOoYN2MypXUbk-SM5gH1Q

what do you guys think?

rarity wise it is over but demand wise it is off by 1 10 rare. it depends on how you value your zodiac dogs and i personally value them at 2 09 rares c:

[leeleecat]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=76122573&userid=938907&signature=V43iGJMvDvaZ0mzfmpibfA

Is this fair??