The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[SkeletonHug]

Is this fair? I'm not really good with warrior cat worth's

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100940808&userid=631866&signature=H99SJeKge3pREamw8rY3pA

And this one, what's the demand kn these foxes compared to the store pets?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100940801&userid=631866&signature=VpcB1NqPcUOLkdrMOabt5A

[Ein.]

Can I get an opinion on this trade?

I would call that overpay on their end.

Alright thanks can I have one more opinion

Edit: this too please I'm outdated on list stuff
trades/viewtrade.php?id=100938904&userid=652660&signature=jz3DnK4vKg-D8o7F8gXHxA

[Wysterinka]

Is this fair? I'm not really good with warrior cat worth's

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100940808&userid=631866&signature=H99SJeKge3pREamw8rY3pA

And this one, what's the demand kn these foxes compared to the store pets?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100940801&userid=631866&signature=VpcB1NqPcUOLkdrMOabt5A

first one unfair to warrior, they go for 3-4 09 rares
second one VERY unfair to top, they offer 6x 2010 rare so 3 09 rares for the foxes, even tho these are just event rares from 2019

[SkeletonHug]

Is this fair? I'm not really good with warrior cat worth's

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100940808&userid=631866&signature=H99SJeKge3pREamw8rY3pA

And this one, what's the demand kn these foxes compared to the store pets?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100940801&userid=631866&signature=VpcB1NqPcUOLkdrMOabt5A

first one unfair to warrior, they go for 3-4 09 rares
second one VERY unfair to top, they offer 6x 2010 rare so 3 09 rares for the foxes, even tho these are just event rares from 2019

Thank you for your help I really appreciate it!!!

[Wysterinka]

Is this fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=100939117&userid=6076&signature=YPg6oWFvI1CJjc2MMIQHJA
Thanks in advance

top - green toxic .25-.5n + ur holly 1.5n
bottom - nontag 1n + nonjewel 1n + items 1 MA (?) + 1 MA + 09 rare + 2x .5n

this makes it VERY unfair to bottom by all the items if you count green tox highest since he is "kinda" close te TD but not TD really

[Poudre~Love]

Lots of pets here. Is it fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100935318&userid=1004200&signature=Rae6BsfbFmagoMm20n-VNw

[Wysterinka]

Lots of pets here. Is it fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100935318&userid=1004200&signature=Rae6BsfbFmagoMm20n-VNw

it's really up to your personal preference, technically they are overpaying you plus they put in the light new lion that many people want...your side has 1 token pet which may or may not be rare but even if, they still overpay by 2 years difference

[arisoup]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=100942391&userid=1020598&signature=PSeH1QEnn2xz6ErjUEJy5Q

? the gap in years is quite big so I'm not really sure

V alright, thank you!

[Wysterinka]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=100942391&userid=1020598&signature=PSeH1QEnn2xz6ErjUEJy5Q

? the gap in years is quite big so I'm not really sure

going by rarities and 2:1 rule not really....but if you calculated by C$ values and preferred more rares to trade with, then it's definitely good

[s a r o s]

I need a bit of help with these trades: 1 & 2

Thanks in advance!