The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Wysterinka]

Hi everyone,
Would this trade be fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83907209&userid=72699&signature=g2z9CoDCzsPNbJzd06nRuQ

Edit*
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83907370&userid=72699&signature=ridF6K1M_XFSP32xtJHgFw
And this one?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83907360&userid=72699&signature=KmS_IW7Fc17ps959m1S1kg

Thanks a lot!

[Whisper~]

I'm not too good with C$ so would this trade be fair?

[Bruno Buccellati]

Would this be fair? >:

[Rbpuppy]

Hi everyone,
Would this trade be fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83907209&userid=72699&signature=g2z9CoDCzsPNbJzd06nRuQ

Edit*
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83907370&userid=72699&signature=ridF6K1M_XFSP32xtJHgFw
And this one?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83907360&userid=72699&signature=KmS_IW7Fc17ps959m1S1kg

Thanks a lot!

The first is unfair to them.
The second is unfair to you.
The third I believe is unfair to them.

[GreenteaLatte]

Hi everyone,
Would this trade be fair?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83907209&userid=72699&signature=g2z9CoDCzsPNbJzd06nRuQ

Edit*
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83907370&userid=72699&signature=ridF6K1M_XFSP32xtJHgFw
And this one?
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83907360&userid=72699&signature=KmS_IW7Fc17ps959m1S1kg

Thanks a lot!

The first is unfair to them.
The second is unfair to you.
The third I believe is unfair to them.

Edit: woops never mind! mixed up the second and third trades. I also agree with Rbpuppy c:

[greenbunny1998]

Is this trade fair for my card dogs?

Thank you.

[MidnightDuchess]

Just wanted to hear some opinions just in case pets are being valued way differently lately.

I was offered this (#1) and told to edit if I wanted. So I edited (#2) because I wanted the originally offered pets but couldn’t really make it fair with any pets so liked so I asked for a good deal less than I believe my pet to be worth, and they sent back (#3) which I believed was highly unfair, was I wrong? Just trying to get my wl pets without overpaying more than I have to.

#1 Trade
#2 Trade
#3 Trade

[MidnightDuchess]

Is this trade fair for my card dogs?

Thank you.

They are offering 3 09 rares worth + some uncommons and newer rares not mentioned because they don’t add up to much
Both of your dogs are worth 2 ‘09 rares and 1 ‘10 rare each as they are from Nov 2008. They need to add about 2 ‘09 rares to be fair rarity wise.

Personal opinion here: Demand wise you could get way more. (I personally demand value those dogs at 3-4 ‘09 rares each as that is what I personally would be willing to pay for them. Others may not, that so, demand is not set for them.)

[SeaCrest]

Just wanted to hear some opinions just in case pets are being valued way differently lately.

I was offered this (#1) and told to edit if I wanted. So I edited (#2) because I wanted the originally offered pets but couldn’t really make it fair with any pets so liked so I asked for a good deal less than I believe my pet to be worth, and they sent back (#3) which I believed was highly unfair, was I wrong? Just trying to get my wl pets without overpaying more than I have to.

#1 Trade
#2 Trade
#3 Trade

1) The Skulls Malk Cat is originally from March 2009. That means it's definitely worth more than the two '16 rares they offered.
2) A 2015 store pet is worth a a mid-2009 rare. This is fairer to you but still about only half of what the cat is worth, yes!
3) Honestly, I feel like this is even worse than the original trade. The Grey Carousel Horse is a Tier 2 Advent worth 4-5 mixed '09 rares. The '17 store pet is worth an early '10 rare, and the '19 store pet is worth a late '10 rare. That brings their side to 2 '09 rares + a '15 rare, definitely not enough for your horse.

[Falco]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83909458&userid=841851&signature=EblPY-ujoEypK7m6FygtQg
I know demand for warriors can be pretty high, like 2 2009 rares for one.