The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[smairy]

Is this fair? I just only recently got the lion and am a little unsure of how well it trades.

Thank you so much!

[punpun.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68722653&userid=48518&signature=T8tFGa0-W-etPYhE_vv7Vg

I know this is unfair to them. But they are more than happy to accept. I’m very wary of trading the whole staff set, especially with them being truedates and my own adoptions. It’s an amazing offer but I’m unsure if I should accept. What do you guys think?
Do staff pets generally go for overpay? Are they hard to get back? Is it a trade you would accept given the chance?
Sorry about all the questions but I have all the staffs so I’m unsure what their like to trade for ^^;;

100 percent unfair for them. that growing white july is equal to the UR pineapple. Honestly except for shima longtail, the old staff pets aren't worth much.. I feel bad for that person lmao

I know it’s unfair. They sent the trade and asked the FTT. I want to know is it worth it and whether I should accept or not.

its also honestly on preference as well. If you are connected with the staff pets than keep them. its pretty hard to find full 2009 og staff pets, but the white july is still much more worth it if you are looking to collect. : ?

[FenrirtheKBD]

How is the demand/rarity on this horse? Should I accept this for my Rose PPS? What is the demand of the rose PPS?

[September Rain]

Thank you! And these two?

Anyone?

Edit: And this?

How about this?
This is for an auction, so I'd appreciate an opinion c:

I've been asking for a couple pages, can anyone help?

[punpun.]

How is the demand/rarity on this horse? Should I accept this for my Rose PPS? What is the demand of the rose PPS?

fairly equal, they are both list pets, but the purple horse is a little more valuable. the rose seems to have more of a demand however. I think if you were to add like an 08/09 rare or 2 onto your side it would be a little more even.

[ruel]

Could I have some help with This trade? If you could PM me the answer it would be appreciated!

[TheLittleBlackCat]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68750604&userid=724943&signature=l0FKtjb6h844jXgtJvPBaQ

Am I asking for too much?

I would consider this only a little bit overpay on their side because of the amount of 2008 rares (pretty much equivalent to a 2017 very rare)

the rose pps is a list pet, while the other vrs are like tier 6 on the september list. Idk i would remove some of the rares from their side and call it even

You're overpaying. The rose pps is worth more than those two advents and the handful of 09' rares.

This is the red rose pps' worth:

IMG_2679.PNG (82.83 KiB) Viewed 51 times

Their side is only really worth a mid or high September (unsure which, you'd need to get that checked)

-

Course, that's only rarity wise. I'm not too sure on the pps' demand worth

[punpun.]

Thank you! And these two?

Anyone?

Edit: And this?

How about this?
This is for an auction, so I'd appreciate an opinion c:

1. and 2. unfair for you, however the first one is a little more fair compared to the 2nd. I think if they added either 2 more vr or 2/3 09 rares it would pretty much even out.
3. pretty fair. decent balance of 09 rares and vrs on their side.
4. fair.

[smairy]

Is this fair? I just only recently got the lion and am a little unsure of how well it trades.

Thank you so much! I would like to get a reply asap ^^

[FenrirtheKBD]

How is the demand/rarity on this horse? Should I accept this for my Rose PPS? What is the demand of the rose PPS?

fairly equal, they are both list pets, but the purple horse is a little more valuable. the rose seems to have more of a demand however. I think if you were to add like an 08/09 rare or 2 onto your side it would be a little more even.

Thank you, second opinion?