The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[♡ yoonie ♡]

im not too good with rare trade- could i get some advice
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98477154&userid=394786&signature=c6FmKuuJpurWMvYJf2_UAw

[candee1501]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98477258&userid=433734&signature=DNKgJKcSmGbHpNpBPYR9xQ

This trade is between me and my mother but I wanted to be sure we were both being mostly fair some overpay on either side isn't a huge deal though.

[CaptainVin11]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98263427&userid=1004931&signature=D7jqJJcEuugdOheCm0lYZg
Been thinking about this trade for a long time and still, I dont know ;; is it fair?

[Pastel-Axle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98263427&userid=1004931&signature=D7jqJJcEuugdOheCm0lYZg
Been thinking about this trade for a long time and still, I dont know ;; is it fair?

This is massive overpay on the spider end due to the age of their pets, as opposed to yours being very recent (the extra uncommon s do not make up for the date gap, your partner may already be aware of this but you should check to make sure in my opinion!)

[employer]

im not too good with rare trade- could i get some advice
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98477154&userid=394786&signature=c6FmKuuJpurWMvYJf2_UAw

this is technically fair. omgsr rats usually trade for around 0.25 non and the august pps is worth 0.25-0.5 non. i personally wouldn't accept this though since the rats have horrible demand and the august pps is one of the most popular pets on the site, so you could definitely get a better offer imo <3

[Pastel-Axle]

im not too good with rare trade- could i get some advice
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98477154&userid=394786&signature=c6FmKuuJpurWMvYJf2_UAw

this is technically fair. omgsr rats usually trade for around 0.25 non and the august pps is worth 0.25-0.5 non. i personally wouldn't accept this though since the rats have horrible demand and the august pps is one of the most popular pets on the site, so you could definitely get a better offer imo <3

Seconding this! While OMGSR rats do have legitimate worth they are incredibly difficult to trade off, and I believe that you’d have a much easier time keeping your August PPS and waiting for a better offer.

[Pyca]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98468312&userid=933497&signature=4RJFG7K0fEP9dQ1dYTFWkQ

any help is appreciated, thank you

[EmilineRose]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=98479215&userid=535911&signature=6gohHFgA2aeKyA4Q2K_cpQ

Could anyone help me on this one?
Pet to item trades aren't in my skill set lol.
If it's unfair, I would appreciate advice on how to change that as well if possible ♡
Thanks a bunch ♡

Edit:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=98479268&userid=535911&signature=K_01w2ZRSsaP9SERpEN7pA
Help on this too?
Thanks so much ♡

[da,]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98479535&userid=652611&signature=dnERRxtOZ0--L1x24AZIuQ

Thoughts? Tysm!

[Pastel-Axle]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=98479535&userid=652611&signature=dnERRxtOZ0--L1x24AZIuQ

Thoughts? Tysm!

It’s technically fair, potentially overpay depending on whether your trading partner values true dates, but I personally wouldn’t take it. The White February trades consistently for 2MAs with good demand. Grinners also go for 2MAs, with a TD one potentially going for 3MAs/0.25n if your trade partner values true dates. Despite this, grinner dogs have poor demand and are thus difficult to trade while your White February has consistently good demand, so I’d hold on to your pet.
Please get a second opinion, but that’s how I see it!