The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Karnaca]

I'm really bad with items, so is this fair? Thanks for any opinions!

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73728034&userid=148610&signature=uYRDevQPQAup2iPyaR6xNg

[the]

Could I get an opinion on this and this, keeping demand in mind? Thanks!

1. Your quantity is adding up to about a blue rose tier (7 mid advents), while their cake dog is lower on the list and worth only 6, so unfair to you.

2. That depends how you personally value the warrior cats. I personally value uncommon warriors at rare '09 and rare warriors at 2 rares '09, so for me their side is worth little more than 5.5 rares '09. Your dog is worth 6-7 rares '09, so I'd say it's unfair to you.

[Poca]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73755057&userid=793079&signature=guql4__ncvQFfZxkN_U6AQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73756743&userid=793079&signature=1kZURInyW6DS_jlq4C_OwQ

Which one is better? Can someone please also tell me what the BW and Tribal is worth? Should i take one?

[monochromia]

ooof

Hi! how much does the cat usually go for?~

[Silver Pandorica]

also, this : sorry i am a helpless child, i promise i will learn the rarities and stuff ;w;

On the other side! I’d love to know as well <3

[AmyEnder]

ooof

Hi! how much does the cat usually go for?~

The UR cat is a high above-gap mainlist, while the Raven is still just an advent and the PPS dragon is a low below-the-gap mainlist. On a technical scale this is unfair to them - demand is really up to you! But on a demand opinion, personally I’ve seen ravens alone go for a bit more!

[LittleJulie]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=73752275&userid=163044&signature=pdFVuaWtbz4yhz2cY_UH1w

Pls help, just came back from hiatus and know nothing about item rarities.
Is this fair? I'm not using the items a lot though so...

Anyone good with item rarities? Thank you!

Pls help :>

[The Last Raven]

ooof

Hi! how much does the cat usually go for?~

The UR cat is a high above-gap mainlist, while the Raven is still just an advent and the PPS dragon is a low below-the-gap mainlist. On a technical scale this is unfair to them - demand is really up to you! But on a demand opinion, personally I’ve seen ravens alone go for a bit more!

The ur cat generally goes for fair trades. Although the raven has good demand I don’t generally see it valued that highly.

[StrawBenny]

fair? thanks!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73758115&userid=754287&signature=oWlomF1tHeiAJgUKm53P9g

[Dancing.cinnamon~]

Help! Please! Would it be fair for just the GWJ and one of the others?

and this bid?