The "Is this a fair trade" Thread

[punpun.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68722653&userid=48518&signature=T8tFGa0-W-etPYhE_vv7Vg

I know this is unfair to them. But they are more than happy to accept. I’m very wary of trading the whole staff set, especially with them being truedates and my own adoptions. It’s an amazing offer but I’m unsure if I should accept. What do you guys think?
Do staff pets generally go for overpay? Are they hard to get back? Is it a trade you would accept given the chance?
Sorry about all the questions but I have all the staffs so I’m unsure what their like to trade for ^^;;

100 percent unfair for them. that growing white july is equal to the UR pineapple. Honestly except for shima longtail, the old staff pets aren't worth much.. I feel bad for that person lmao

[kyum-]

Click me is this fair demand wise

an '08 vr = 2 '09 r + 1 '10 r, so i would say it's just fair rarity-wise, since the other pets don't do much. dogs have better demand than rats as well.

[GoldenSlumbers]

Click me is this fair demand wise

an '08 vr = 2 '09 r + 1 '10 r, so i would say it's just fair rarity-wise, since the other pets don't do much. dogs have better demand than rats as well.

thank you may i have another opinion

[emjayy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68722653&userid=48518&signature=T8tFGa0-W-etPYhE_vv7Vg

I know this is unfair to them. But they are more than happy to accept. I’m very wary of trading the whole staff set, especially with them being truedates and my own adoptions. It’s an amazing offer but I’m unsure if I should accept. What do you guys think?
Do staff pets generally go for overpay? Are they hard to get back? Is it a trade you would accept given the chance?
Sorry about all the questions but I have all the staffs so I’m unsure what their like to trade for ^^;;

100 percent unfair for them. that growing white july is equal to the UR pineapple. Honestly except for shima longtail, the old staff pets aren't worth much.. I feel bad for that person lmao

I know it’s unfair. They sent the trade and asked the FTT. I want to know is it worth it and whether I should accept or not.

[September Rain]

Thank you! And these two?

Anyone?

Edit: And this?

How about this?
This is for an auction, so I'd appreciate an opinion c:

[punpun.]

Hellooo!
I really like both of these trades, which one is more fair for my kitsune mask dog both rarity and demand wise??
1
2
Any help would be amazing, thanks!

h e lp

personally speaking, the 2nd one seems more appealing because everyone loves the 2013 summer event and that other store pet is also pretty popular, but the first one is a little more in your favor. Honestly this one is more about preference.

[nishi]

Would this be fair? Please and thank you!

[punpun.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=68722653&userid=48518&signature=T8tFGa0-W-etPYhE_vv7Vg

I know this is unfair to them. But they are more than happy to accept. I’m very wary of trading the whole staff set, especially with them being truedates and my own adoptions. It’s an amazing offer but I’m unsure if I should accept. What do you guys think?
Do staff pets generally go for overpay? Are they hard to get back? Is it a trade you would accept given the chance?
Sorry about all the questions but I have all the staffs so I’m unsure what their like to trade for ^^;;

100 percent unfair for them. that growing white july is equal to the UR pineapple. Honestly except for shima longtail, the old staff pets aren't worth much.. I feel bad for that person lmao

I know it’s unfair. They sent the trade and asked the FTT. I want to know is it worth it and whether I should accept or not.

if they understand what they are doing, then Id accept. the white july dog is worth at least 20 2008/2009 rares.

[Smaug The Dragon]

Are any of these fair?
1. Trade offer one
2. Trade two (what should be added?)
3. Trade Three (fair demand wise? What are both worth?)
4. Trade Four (what should be added?)

What's better? What closet and has something to be added?

[GoldenSlumbers]

Click me is this fair demand wise

an '08 vr = 2 '09 r + 1 '10 r, so i would say it's just fair rarity-wise, since the other pets don't do much. dogs have better demand than rats as well.

thank you may i have another opinion