The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[LavenderHaze]

Is this a fair trade? https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97012966&userid=677591&signature=sv7MCyI6S-jlCFjIgboUbw

Wrong link

Fixed I think.

Unfair to you with the 2:1 rule. a 2014 common is worth 2 15 com, 4 16 com, etc. Making your side worth 8 2016 commons, which their side doesn't meet.

[Dear Deer]

Would a rare from the 2014 Egypt event be fair for one of the 2021 giraffe store pets? I know with the 2:1 rule my 2014 rare is theoretically worth 14 2021 rares, but I'm absolutely clueless as to how being a store pet effects value.

thanks in advance for any help
ʕ •ᴥ• ʔ

[Aidoneus]

Is this trade fair? Thanks in advance for any help!

[LavenderHaze]

Would a rare from the 2014 Egypt event be fair for one of the 2021 giraffe store pets? I know with the 2:1 rule my 2014 rare is theoretically worth 14 2021 rares, but I'm absolutely clueless as to how being a store pet effects value.

thanks in advance for any help
ʕ •ᴥ• ʔ

No, this is unfair o your giraffe. Store pets are iffy in that they don't really follow the 2:1 rule when trading for regular rares. I think theres been some changes in the store pet values recently but I've always valued 2021 store pets at a late 10- and early 11 rare

[AddyBoo77]

Is this fair? I’m not good with the worth of items -any help is appreciated!

[mauracat]

no not at all

[Boo & Shady]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97010550&userid=45133&signature=W_EfkL5O45Ok9fcD80-RFA

I don’t have particular interest in the cinnabun but my end goal is to trade for a UR peach or UR Bwolf, so how easy would it be to trade off the Cinnabun? Is demand very high? Or would the older items be better?
Thanks!

[Taro_Queen]

Is this fair to the TD full Zodiac set?

[puppybarkstoo]

hi all ^^ i'm a new user still learning the ropes... i was sent this trade offer, but i don't know if it's fair? here's the link https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97010227&userid=1025566&signature=YOeuWViBz1hQ2P7HVW65OA

[Buddha78]

hi all ^^ i'm a new user still learning the ropes... i was sent this trade offer, but i don't know if it's fair? here's the link https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97010227&userid=1025566&signature=YOeuWViBz1hQ2P7HVW65OA

Not fair to you. I wouldn't except. They want overpay for their 2021 pet.