[NEW!!!] "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [READ RULES]

[- Alice -]

doot

Is this trade fair? Little unsure as how lists work now aha

[amarok.]

This?
If I value the red cerb at 3-4 nons would it be fair? What'll need to be added if not?

They’re a toxic short of 3 nons. So unfair to you.

Thank you. Second opinion?

I second what Squea said.
But I'd like to add that I personally reckon there's a chance you could get a toxic out of the change they're offering, since the store pets can go for anything between an advent to a september. It's a risky move in this economy but store pets are in demand at the moment. If you could persuade them to add a balloon dog to their side i'd take it, personally. I'd also like to add that rarity wise, the blue android is worth more than the red cerb alone, as is the liontail.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85333984&userid=819890&signature=AMQdgy-9gcnNOBKzbQqsDQ

This?

they're overpaying. the dragon plush is worth 4c$ and skitters is worth 6c$. an '11 rare is worth 16-19c$ according to the worth guide, and considering it's the end of the year that'll bump a tiny bit more, too.

[w h a t]

Sorry, bulk trade

So, i think i overpaid a lot for those, but i want to be sure, i did 1 old UC for every 4 OMSC-UC dogs.

Just to be clear, you really did. At least in my opinion. especially with all of the uncommons far older than the common/lower offered!
for a comparison, these are a few trades i've had trading down bulk uncommon for bulk common. Notice the unc are much closer in date. 1 2 3

I know that demand and fairness are highly subjective for uncommon and below pets, but the older an uncommon, the more easily comparable it is to a young rare. That was a lot of overpay on your side.

[Zeena]

Here is my trade, any opinions?:

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85335466&userid=424987&signature=2v3JvPyWknqUlr6e4Z1iCw

Happy holidays!

[Mya.]

How's this?
please include fairness and the demand

[- Alice -]

doot

Is this trade fair? Little unsure as how lists work now aha

[Jawy.EXE]

Sorry, bulk trade

So, i think i overpaid a lot for those, but i want to be sure, i did 1 old UC for every 4 OMSC-UC dogs.

Just to be clear, you really did. At least in my opinion. especially with all of the uncommons far older than the common/lower offered!
for a comparison, these are a few trades i've had trading down bulk uncommon for bulk common. Notice the unc are much closer in date. 1 2 3

I know that demand and fairness are highly subjective for uncommon and below pets, but the older an uncommon, the more easily comparable it is to a young rare. That was a lot of overpay on your side.

Ye, i thought they cabcelled and i was like "??? I am alteady paying a lot" but it was another dude. Im just overpaying bc i want to get all 17/18/19 dogs today ooor tomorrow

[SpiritX]

Fairly new so don't know if this is fair or not, any advice?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85336250&userid=981441&signature=LsOh9YXth_zMyfue6-On4A

[Spine]

Fairly new so don't know if this is fair or not, any advice?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85336250&userid=981441&signature=LsOh9YXth_zMyfue6-On4A

i'd personally say they're over, since people use the 4:1 ratio for rares, so 4 uncommons = a rare from the same year. though personally i wouldn't take it because of rarity

[amarok.]

Fairly new so don't know if this is fair or not, any advice?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85336250&userid=981441&signature=LsOh9YXth_zMyfue6-On4A

they're overpaying by a fair amount. by the 2;1 rule (where a pet is worth double the amount of a pet a year younger) the '17 uncommon butterfly wolf is fair on its own.