The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[karachi]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=81327741&userid=795826&signature=Y7rbOQLs0HjDxm2nutTocQ

Thanks for all the help!

[negati]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=81325761&userid=44306&signature=iGYVowQ4XckAS99m3Ev3wQ

Disregard that it is cancelled - I think it was an accident - it's a bid for an auction that is about to end

I just need to know, is that rat really worth a sorb?

[swiftheart54]

is this pretty fair? thanks in advance
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81327886&userid=351237&signature=c-SCudwhMmgKqpuCAKfy8A

[honeycreeper]

my trading partner days that they value 2014 store pets at 2 '09 rares each, what could be added to make this fair to us both? thank you for any help!
boomp

honey

[GreenteaLatte]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=81325761&userid=44306&signature=iGYVowQ4XckAS99m3Ev3wQ

Disregard that it is cancelled - I think it was an accident - it's a bid for an auction that is about to end

I just need to know, is that rat really worth a sorb?

Yes but due to the low demand, seems like people like to offer less for it. I've traded my omgsr rats for a sorb's worth each but people seem to value it even less now.

my trading partner days that they value 2014 store pets at 2 '09 rares each, what could be added to make this fair to us both? thank you for any help!
boomp

honey

2014 store pets are worth 1 09 rare each so this trade is already fair to both sides but if you are willing to follow the trading partner's value, then you'll need to add another vr 09 pet or 2 09 rares.

[MoMoYA]

is this pretty fair? thanks in advance
trades/viewtrade.php?id=81327886&userid=351237&signature=c-SCudwhMmgKqpuCAKfy8A

Yeah honestly I think that’s pretty good.

Could I get some other opinions of this?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=81325900&userid=950685&signature=9eNaYjk2GBsJE4Tod8qCXA

I think that’s unfair to them. The dog’s true date is actually ‘09, I believe, so you would need two ‘09 rares, or 4 ‘10 rares, you only have one ‘10 and a ‘14, which isn’t equal. As for the C$, it still doesn’t balance out much. Maybe even more, depends how they value the dog. Horses are also really low demand and hard to trade off.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=81307456&userid=638504&signature=M5ygsRdYPYun_8noim14nA

Is this fair, considering rarity and your personal demand? Would you accept this? Thank you for any help!!

I wouldn’t. Personally I’d value the apple more, mainly because I feel like items are less demand than pets, that sort of thing

[SoulStreamR]

Hi, would this be enough UC for my Store Pet?
XXX
Thank you in advanced!

[Fedsat]

Opinions on this trade?

Thanks

[MoMoYA]

Hi, would this be enough UC for my Store Pet?
XXX
Thank you in advanced!

Personally I would say absolutely not. Not at all. Usually I would ask for rares, but if I was trading it for Uncommons, I’d ask for maybe three times that, maybe four. Again I probably value it higher or lower than others, so it’s just an opinion, but I would say no.

Opinions on this trade?

Thanks

Again, not really. I feel like you are overpaying, they’d have to offer more. If you see, let’s take their rare and one of your closer/same year rares and match them up. Fair, I assume? So now take your other three rares and their few commons and very commons, and one uncommon. IMO commons and VC, and only one UC would be terribly unfair for three rares, especially because your rates are older ones. Again just an opinion, and I’m really really sorry for posting so much, I’m probably annoying, I’m just tryna help people. Again it all depends how you value your rares, some will think that that’s fair, others won’t.

[GreenteaLatte]

Could I get some other opinions of this?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=81325900&userid=950685&signature=9eNaYjk2GBsJE4Tod8qCXA

I think that’s unfair to them. The dog’s true date is actually ‘09, I believe, so you would need two ‘09 rares, or 4 ‘10 rares, you only have one ‘10 and a ‘14, which isn’t equal. As for the C$, it still doesn’t balance out much. Maybe even more, depends how they value the dog. Horses are also really low demand and hard to trade off.

I'll have to disagree. Just the cs itself is worth around a tier 2 advent list. That's more than just 2 09 rares.

Opinions on this trade?

Thanks

Again, not really. I feel like you are overpaying, they’d have to offer more. If you see, let’s take their rare and one of your closer/same year rares and match them up. Fair, I assume? So now take your other three rares and their few commons and very commons, and one uncommon. IMO commons and VC, and only one UC would be terribly unfair for three rares, especially because your rates are older ones. Again just an opinion, and I’m really really sorry for posting so much, I’m probably annoying, I’m just tryna help people. Again it all depends how you value your rares, some will think that that’s fair, others won’t.

Please stop giving false advice. That sitting cat is a re-release from 2009 Christmas.
Edit: Just to add on, the bottom trade is one 2013 rare short from a 09 rare.