The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [rule about quoting!]

[.: pop 101 :.]

I want more opinions.

It's unfair to the Bone PPS either way.
It's a big gap for a pet that is never destined for the any list, at least not for a long, long time. It's simply not rare enough, and probably never will be.

So the Bone PPS has more demand than the lion PPS?

[November.Fox]

Fair?

Demand Wise I say unfair to the top
but get another opinion but I say unfair to top but lucky if they accept

Only because Raven is extremely high demand

Really? I was told it should be fair by someone else, (Low September should equal Two mid advents if I'm not mistaken. Thus, Raven and a 2 marionettes/1 marionette and the bunny {Marionettes and the bunny are low advents, so adding both would be about a mid advent}) but I was really only unsure of the store dogs and adding two Marionettes. I figured the cat, mid advent, would make up for the other marionette and 2 store dogs at least (If not all) and adding the rares should've made up for the store dog set. Am I wrong?


Second opinions, someone?

[sylveonite]

I want more opinions.

It's unfair to the Bone PPS either way.
It's a big gap for a pet that is never destined for the any list, at least not for a long, long time. It's simply not rare enough, and probably never will be.

So the Bone PPS has more demand than the lion PPS?

Yes^^ I belivie.

[Fat Unicorn]

Fair?

Demand Wise I say unfair to the top
but get another opinion but I say unfair to top but lucky if they accept

Only because Raven is extremely high demand

Really? I was told it should be fair by someone else, (Low September should equal Two mid advents if I'm not mistaken. Thus, Raven and a 2 marionettes/1 marionette and the bunny {Marionettes and the bunny are low advents, so adding both would be about a mid advent}) but I was really only unsure of the store dogs and adding two Marionettes. I figured the cat, mid advent, would make up for the other marionette and 2 store dogs at least (If not all) and adding the rares should've made up for the store dog set. Am I wrong?


Second opinions, someone?

That's unfair to you Sasha. c:

[November.Fox]

Demand Wise I say unfair to the top
but get another opinion but I say unfair to top but lucky if they accept

Only because Raven is extremely high demand

Really? I was told it should be fair by someone else, (Low September should equal Two mid advents if I'm not mistaken. Thus, Raven and a 2 marionettes/1 marionette and the bunny {Marionettes and the bunny are low advents, so adding both would be about a mid advent}) but I was really only unsure of the store dogs and adding two Marionettes. I figured the cat, mid advent, would make up for the other marionette and 2 store dogs at least (If not all) and adding the rares should've made up for the store dog set. Am I wrong?


Second opinions, someone?

That's unfair to you Sasha. c:

Thank you, I was following your advice in the first place, and I thought so cx Just wanted to be sure because the pets were a bit different than what I originally asked about xD I trust your judegment completely, thank you for reassuring me of that <3

[.: pop 101 :.]

I want more opinions.

It's unfair to the Bone PPS either way.
It's a big gap for a pet that is never destined for the any list, at least not for a long, long time. It's simply not rare enough, and probably never will be.

So the Bone PPS has more demand than the lion PPS?

I need one more opinion.

Im a little attatched to this lion because its demand.

[brad!]

I want more opinions.

It's unfair to the Bone PPS either way.
It's a big gap for a pet that is never destined for the any list, at least not for a long, long time. It's simply not rare enough, and probably never will be.

So the Bone PPS has more demand than the lion PPS?

It's highly unlikely you're going to get a better offer than that, you should take it.
The Bone PPS has good demand, and what they've offered you is a rather big jump. You're pretty much at the top of the advent list. Since the list factors in rarity and demand, I would say it has better demand, yes.

[Fat Unicorn]

@ above: Demandwise, the August PPS Lion has more demand than the Bone PPS. ^^ But yes, I do agree with Beguile.

[Kyar]

I want more opinions.

It's unfair to the Bone PPS either way.
It's a big gap for a pet that is never destined for the any list, at least not for a long, long time. It's simply not rare enough, and probably never will be.

So the Bone PPS has more demand than the lion PPS?

I need one more opinion.

Im a little attatched to this lion because its demand.

I'm not sure what the trade is but a bone PPS is worth way more than an August lion even with demand.

[montyboy101]

Fair?