The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread / NEW THREAD

[screamingrainfrog]

Hello! Can I get an opinion on this?
I have no idea how much the rat is worth or what it trades for
Thank you in advance :)

[Pixje]

I just received a new offer for the tigerdog..

Im not sure what the value of 6 nons is for it in chickendollars so any help appreciated, thanks in advamce

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110987217&userid=844014&signature=8iOGi7F9t8N6tloTGvPOEQ

[jprspereira]

I just received a new offer for the tigerdog..

Im not sure what the value of 6 nons is for it in chickendollars so any help appreciated, thanks in advamce

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=110987217&userid=844014&signature=8iOGi7F9t8N6tloTGvPOEQ

I'd argue their side is roughly 4400C$ (but big part of that is 4000C$ from UR Flamingo which has BAD demand) in pets. Then they add 4600C$, so 9000C$ total.

UR Tiger is 6 nons so at least 12000C$. They're down 3000C$ and that's if you'd want the UR Flamingo.

[V_Khai]

My spouse halted me to trading my older pets without getting some input so... asking about this one since I'm not familiar with true values.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=110986802&userid=3693&signature=jF5GITgfWVXBHLULwFt7aQ

good spouse! :] it's very unfair to you. based on years and rarities, their side of the trade doesn't even come close to your pps side.

[The Lady Amalthea]

Hi please can I have some help

I don't know what the Dutch bunny is worth
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110907603&userid=938809&signature=mvvhJdapEAXWYYSEfCCZ0Q

[-Rainbowwwie-]

Hello are these fair and if not what should be added?
1) trades/viewtrade.php?id=110969377&userid=223692&signature=MLbwtvlvuSiHbLk4NBjOLw

2) trades/viewtrade.php?id=110970829&userid=223692&signature=znSArLKcO5s8XQe7mKoQrw
Thank you

[angst]

I really appreciate the help on this. Does this new offer look more fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=110932722&userid=315273&signature=peuhcX2vw97tQ-UWCIfhjw

I’m really tempted but I need some help to figure out how it adds up.
Piratemolly

This looks to me like they're overpaying a decent amount.

[Vanendra]

Is this fair? And if not, what kind of years and rarities would be fair for the 2009 BW?

View Trade Here

Any help at all appreciated, thank you in advance!

[Audrey_Bee]

Is this fair? And if not, what kind of years and rarities would be fair for the 2009 BW?

View Trade Here

Any help at all appreciated, thank you in advance!

If you follow the 2:1 rule while also taking demand and bulk into account, their side would be worth roughly just under a 2009 rare. I'd personally want them to add a 2009 rare worth to make it fair

[sweetsakura]

please help mee :,>

Hey! I'm so sorry I only just logged back in and didn't see this! Unfortunately it looked quite unfair to you as the recent store pets are usually valued at an old rare, their side even with bulk adds up to probably a 2020 rare and that's being generous:((

ahh! i appreciate the input, no worries.
ohh that's a shamee :<

how many recent rares make up an old rare? so i know for the future?

thank you!!