The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[ĸιттιe]

I already completed this trade. but I was wondering, is this fair? I just wanted to see if the person was honest lol

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83256327&userid=952056&signature=6qJSF_h_5-U-MkCutJ3HUA

Unfortunately, this was pretty unfair to you. Their side =
- 17 '16 uncommons
- 2 '17 uncommons
- 2 '19 uncommons

This adds up to about 1 '12 rare (if I did the math correctly haha) (valuing each item at a '16 uncommon, which means that's even more than it's really worth). You're overpaying by two years

lmao I screwed myself xddd glad to see people are honest am I right :||||

[Ghoulflower]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83262907&userid=761439&signature=3Ba8id_wOa0NIsJ2ef0aXg

Would this be fair? Thanks!!

[katsdere]

ah okay so i really help with this tradee bagh uwu
im not good at high rare trades, and i was wondering if this was fair demand or rare wise?
any and all help is greatly appreciated tyy!

[williamjwu4]

ah okay so i really help with this tradee bagh uwu
im not good at high rare trades, and i was wondering if this was fair demand or rare wise?
any and all help is greatly appreciated tyy!

I'd say the top is overpaying. The UR Holly goes for 1.5 nons, same as your dragon; Their tier 7 advent list and tier 1 advent would just be overpay for your tier 6 advent. I'd accept c:

[lucky333123]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83262907&userid=761439&signature=3Ba8id_wOa0NIsJ2ef0aXg

Would this be fair? Thanks!!

I would say it is unfair to the bun because the bun is an OMGSR while one VR doesn't make up the difference. In the end, it depends on how you and your partner values the pets.

[MuddyPawprints]

Thanks in advance for any opinions! I'm trying to "trade up" to eventually get the 2017 UR Fennec Fox. I have been offered this trade as a way to get me there, but I have no idea if it's actually fair. I'm used to a couple VRs for one OMGSR (depending on original release year), so I'm a bit stumped. Any and all advise appreciated! As a note, the UR banana is the only OMGSR I currently have.

Fair?

while the UR banana is omgsr, its not in very high demand like the zodiacs tend to be, especially as a full set. not sure about the VR '18 but id personally take this

[sunstream.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83263761&userid=891090&signature=S1FUglVlTHwIzm5unzZEkA
Is this fair? I need quick replies please :0

[williamjwu4]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=83263761&userid=891090&signature=S1FUglVlTHwIzm5unzZEkA
Is this fair? I need quick replies please :0

I would say the other side is overpaying. Your sunback usually goes for around 2.5 nons, and so does the moonswirl (They usually go for 1:1 swaps)

[♥HazelNightmare]

Is this trade fair?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=83263338&userid=138535&signature=GqdqCgDwXe58wn9_qBjHNQ

If using list bottom is 5-6 09 rares and top is 4 and a half 09 rares. They would need to add another 09 rare to make it more fair to you. Any demand is subjective and If you don’t use list they would be over .

[sunstream.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=83263761&userid=891090&signature=S1FUglVlTHwIzm5unzZEkA
Is this fair? I need quick replies please :0

I would say the other side is overpaying. Your sunback usually goes for around 2.5 nons, and so does the moonswirl (They usually go for 1:1 swaps)

Thanks, any other opinions?