The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread - Please use this one!

[Metax]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=30234732&userid=508490&signature=oUEQL8qly2Ryu5y8Xcqjxw
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1LfelG0PXw
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... h0BQKmlqFQ

Which one of these bids is the best? I'm really thinking about them, but can't say which is best... Any help would be appreciated!

Second or third ^^

[Shiny Sylveon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=30234732&userid=508490&signature=oUEQL8qly2Ryu5y8Xcqjxw
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1LfelG0PXw
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... h0BQKmlqFQ

Which one of these bids is the best? I'm really thinking about them, but can't say which is best... Any help would be appreciated!

Second or third ^^

Do you see which one is best? I'm not too good with rarity and date and stuff...

[Metax]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=30234732&userid=508490&signature=oUEQL8qly2Ryu5y8Xcqjxw
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1LfelG0PXw
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... h0BQKmlqFQ

Which one of these bids is the best? I'm really thinking about them, but can't say which is best... Any help would be appreciated!

Second or third ^^

Do you see which one is best? I'm not too good with rarity and date and stuff...

They're almost equal ^^;

[wolfiebaby]

Does anyone know if this is fair?

[Metax]

Does anyone know if this is fair?

Seems unfair to the Malk cat ^^

[Celozon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... u5y8Xcqjxw
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1LfelG0PXw
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... h0BQKmlqFQ

Which one of these bids is the best? I'm really thinking about them, but can't say which is best... Any help would be appreciated!

Second or third ^^

Do you see which one is best? I'm not too good with rarity and date and stuff...

They're almost equal ^^;

Actually the second one is considerably better. Both in rarity and considering that it has early '09 pets unlike the third one.

[Roxie x Titas]

I'm running an Auction with my Green-Fronted Holly Dog.
Which bid is worth accepting? Are these fair?

Bid Number One

Bid Number Two

Bid Number Three

Bid Number Four

Bid Number Five

Bid Number Six

# 1 has 45 items
# 2 has 25 items
# 3 has 62 items
# 4 has 69 items
# 5 had 142 items
# 6 has 435 items

~ RT

None of those are fair to you, or worth accepting in my opinion. They all consist of fairly recent items(in comparison to the dog and when it was released originally) that were relatively easy to get.

Agreed. All of those look unfair to you.

I know that all of these are unfair, but what could be added to

Bid Number Six

To make it fair?

~ RT

[Ghoul (gone)]

Is this fair? Thankyou!

[Celozon]

I know that all of these are unfair, but what could be added to

Bid Number Six

To make it fair?

~ RT

Items aren't exactly the same as pets, we can't just say 'add this many items from Halloween 2012 and it will be exactly fair'. Items don't have set values, and even if they did each item would technically have a different value based on year, demand, how many were released, and whether there were several different types of the item and how easy it was to get all of them. It is extremely hard to give an accurate number of what is and isn't fair for a rares list pet. The best that we can do most of the time is tell you whether the trade is approximately fair.

That said, the green-fronted is at the top of the advent list, its worth about 9 '09 rares. The sender of bid number 6 would probably need to double their offer or more. But considering that not very many people even have that many Halloween items, and thats the only thing your looking for, your probably not going to get an offer that is enough to make it 'fair'. Halloween items are in high demand during October. *shrugs*

[Midna]

I need some help...^^
Is this fair? And also this one? And which trade is better?