The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Griffin Torrens]

Back again on the hunt for C$ and got this offer on my jeweled Liontail.
I'm less interested in pets so looking for art/adopt money.
Is it fair or should I wait for a better offer? Thanks!

[Disintegration]

is this fair?

[darling feathers]

help please

xxx
feathers

[Miikkuli90]

Hi! Can somebody help with this item trade with rare pets? I know very little about item values, but as long as this is pretty fair I could accept and trade away my items: trades/viewtrade.php?id=91050938&userid=493423&signature=VAKElESobyGTDjxjDHhG3g

I just have some older items here, that I'm uncertain about.

[sapphirelion]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91109551&userid=369541&signature=ZtryY9Va5oxUmU5Ogcu60A
Is this one fair?
I'm unsure as its items for pets..

And what about this one?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91110102

I’m unsure on the first trade and the second trade we can’t see, you’d need the link at the bottom of the trade

[Redbird]

Hi! Can somebody help with this item trade with rare pets? I know very little about item values, but as long as this is pretty fair I could accept and trade away my items: trades/viewtrade.php?id=91050938&userid=493423&signature=VAKElESobyGTDjxjDHhG3g

I just have some older items here, that I'm uncertain about.

Yeah, this is unfair to you by quite a lot. Balloon to Spoopy sign would be plenty fair or overpay, imo. Probably leaning overpay.

[Shadow_of_Mystery]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=91109551&userid=369541&signature=ZtryY9Va5oxUmU5Ogcu60A
Is this one fair?
I'm unsure as its items for pets..

And what about this one?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91110102&userid=369541&signature=UbP6OMYOIQc6Q8IJKecyuw

[sry, now's the correct link]

[Miikkuli90]

Hi! Can somebody help with this item trade with rare pets? I know very little about item values, but as long as this is pretty fair I could accept and trade away my items: trades/viewtrade.php?id=91050938&userid=493423&signature=VAKElESobyGTDjxjDHhG3g

I just have some older items here, that I'm uncertain about.

Yeah, this is unfair to you by quite a lot. Balloon to Spoopy sign would be plenty fair or overpay, imo. Probably leaning overpay.

Thanks so much for the evaluation! I'll cancel this then. ^^

[Vanrouge]

It's been a long time since I traded properly, is this a good trade? (Including date swap)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=91112118&userid=429963&signature=Rl2wr43HI3L5bfSzRwEF6A

[ahirked]

How much C$ should they add to make this fair?

I'm bad at C$ math but all I know is those staff pets have a lot of demand - they don't really have any more pets I'm interested in other than the ones they've added here which isn't fair to my side as-is, but I'd like to make this work out for them somehow.

for the record, I'm unaware of exactly what the demand for these pets is, so I'm going to bypass that since demand is user-regulated anyway. demand is up to you and your partner.

their side:
- 1x 2015 r, 3x 2015 uc (= just under a 2012 uncommon)
- 6x 2016 uc (=~2012 common)
- 2017 r (= 2012 omgsc)
- 2x 2018 uc (= 2014 omgsc, but that's getting into relatively ridic denominations)
== 2012 uncommon, 2012 common, 2x 2018 uc

your side:
- 14x 2012 uc
- 1x 2018 vc
== 3 2012 rares, 2 2012 uc, 1 2018 vc

essentially, the 2015 rare, 3x 2015 uc and 2017 rare = 1 2012 uncommons on your side.
that leaves 3 2012 rares, 1 2012 uc, 1 2018 vc (your side); and 2012 common and 2x 2018 uc worth (their side).
to make it easier I'm just going to calculate your respective c$ worths.

3x 2012 r = ~15c$ ea. (= ~45c$)
2012 uc = 7-7.5c$
2018 vc = 0.375c$
== ~53c$

2012 c = 3.5-4c$
2x 2018 uc = 1.5c$ ea. (= 3c$)
== ~6.5-7c$

so they need to add about 46.5-47c$ worth. I think. the earlier pets + low rarities made me confused, sorry! get a second opinion if needs be but I think this is relatively sound calculation ;;

Hi! Can somebody help with this item trade with rare pets? I know very little about item values, but as long as this is pretty fair I could accept and trade away my items: trades/viewtrade.php?id=91050938&userid=493423&signature=VAKElESobyGTDjxjDHhG3g

I just have some older items here, that I'm uncertain about.

Yeah, this is unfair to you by quite a lot. Balloon to Spoopy sign would be plenty fair or overpay, imo. Probably leaning overpay.

okay bottom side:
- teddy = 2010 uc
- pink love gear, chinese lanterns (x2), chibi snake, balloon, wings, staff (x3), belted boots, snowflake socks, long warm coat, pudding bat = 2011 uc ea. (total = 13 2011 uc)
- seahorse = 2012 uc
- halloween bg, spoopy, corn stalks (x2), voodoo, shiny mask (x2), wreath = 2013 uc ea. (total = 8 2013 uc)
- rose, heart balloon, brooch, sun wings, bat wings, scythe, jail hoodie = 2014 c/uc ea. (total = ~5 2014 uc)
- snowy window (x2) = 2014 c/uc ea.
- glitter (x3) = 2015 c/uc ea.
- standing stone, mushroom = 2015 uc ea. (= 2 2015 uc)
- empty nightsky, empty space (x2), tree (x2), terrariam, luminis cloud (x3) = 2016 c/uc ea.
- crows (x3) = 2016 uc ea.
- autumn leaves (x10), scarecrow = 2016 c/uc ea.
- blind eyes gold = 2016 uc
- flowy wigs (x3) = 2017 c/uc ea.
- animal egg, plushies (x7), resort chip, seeds (x2), wigs (x3) = 2018 uc ea. (except for the resort chip and seeds, which I think are more common value)
- tent black = 2018 common
christ there's so many items
- with the 2018 christmas sets I'm going to value them at a common a-piece, and there's 112 items = 112 2018 commons = ~30-40 2018 uncommons
- everything else onwards is c/uc unless a plushie, those tend to be uncommons

---------------------------

the 2010 r on their side == 4 2010 uncommons, so that covers:
- teddy bear
- 6x 2011 items (since 2010 uc = 2 2011 uc)

the 2011 r == 4 2011 uc which covers:
- 4x 2011 items on your side

this leaves 3 2011 uc, 2012 uc, and all the other items unaccounted for.

I agree, this is very unfair to you.